mic_none

Wikipedia:Requests for arbitration/Statistics 2010 Source: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Requests_for_arbitration/Statistics_2010

This page presents arbitration data and statistics for 2010. For other years see:


Requests

[edit]
  • Legend: A=Accept, D=Decline, R=Recuse, C=Comment, I=Inactive/away, N=Not eligible.

Case requests

[edit]
  • Requests: 78; average duration: 6.4 days; accepted: 14 (18%); declined: 52 (67%); disposed by motion: 6 (8%); withdrawn: 6 (8%).

Involving 2010 arbs only

[edit]
Case requests involving 2010 arbs only
Request Opened Closed Days Disp A D R C I Car Chl Cor Fay Fri Her Kir Kni Mai New Ris Rle Rog She Sir Sts Vas Wiz
John J. Bulten 06:46, 23-Dec-2010 19:05, 25-Dec-2010 3 Declined 0 4 0 0 1 I N N D D D N D N N N
YellowMonkey 16:38, 30-Nov-2010 21:16, 24-Dec-2010 24 Motion 2 6 0 1 1 D A I N N D D C D N D D A N N N
Cousin Marriage 10:23, 4-Dec-2010 01:30, 14-Dec-2010 10 Declined 0 6 0 0 2 D I I N N D D D D N D N N N
Ejaculation Photos 22:04, 10-Dec-2010 01:29, 14-Dec-2010 3 Declined 0 7 0 0 2 D I I N N D D D D D N D N N N
Money multiplier 22:37, 1-Dec-2010 18:02, 3-Dec-2010 2 Declined 0 5 0 0 1 D I I N N D D D N D N N N
WikipediaExperts 20:23, 29-Nov-2010 18:46, 30-Nov-2010 1 Declined 0 5 0 0 1 I D N N D D D D N N N N
Military history POV-bias 19:19, 28-Nov-2010 13:18, 30-Nov-2010 2 Accepted 7 0 2 0 1 A I A N N R A A A N R A A N N N
Adnan Oktar 14:15, 19-Nov-2010 10:51, 25-Nov-2010 6 Declined 0 5 0 0 1 D I N N D D N D D N N N
MickMacNee 15:56, 12-Nov-2010 10:47, 25-Nov-2010 13 Declined 4 5 0 0 1 D I A N N D D A D N D A A N N N
Longevity 23:45, 18-Nov-2010 14:47, 22-Nov-2010 4 Accepted 8 0 1 0 2 R I A N N A A A A N A A A I N N
Eroberer 21:38, 7-Nov-2010 22:12, 15-Nov-2010 8 Declined 0 5 0 1 2 D I N N D D D N C D I N N
Edward321 10:42, 25-Oct-2010 23:35, 7-Nov-2010 14 Declined 1 7 0 0 2 D I D N N D D D D N D A I N N
Pumpie 13:51, 11-Oct-2010 17:17, 20-Oct-2010 9 Declined 0 5 0 2 2 I C N N D C D D D D I N N
Cultural Judaism 17:12, 5-Oct-2010 16:07, 11-Oct-2010 6 Declined 0 5 0 0 3 I D N N D D I D D I N N
Transcendental Meditation 2 03:20, 21-Sep-2010 07:23, 1-Oct-2010 10 Declined 0 5 1 0 2 I D N N D I D D D R N N
Stevertigo 2 23:47, 26-Sep-2010 17:15, 29-Sep-2010 3 Accepted 8 0 0 0 3 I A A N N A A A A I A A I N N
Secret 18:44, 22-Sep-2010 01:49, 23-Sep-2010 0 Withdrawn 0 1 0 0 3 I N N I D I N N
MOS:JP – Romanization for words of English origin 22:04, 7-Sep-2010 14:49, 21-Sep-2010 14 Declined 0 5 0 1 3 I D N N C D D D I D I N N
Disburbed: Asylum (Release Date) 06:19, 27-Aug-2010 03:17, 30-Aug-2010 3 Declined 0 7 0 0 4 D I D I N N D D D D I D I N N
Cabal: World War II article 15:08, 23-Aug-2010 03:17, 30-Aug-2010 7 Declined 0 7 0 0 4 D I D I N N D D D D I D I N N
Blablaaa 22:06, 31-Jul-2010 20:19, 19-Aug-2010 19 Declined 1 6 3 0 3 D A I I N N R D D R D R I D D N N
State Church of the Roman Empire 15:50, 11-Aug-2010 13:49, 15-Aug-2010 4 Declined 0 7 0 0 2 D I I N N D D D D D D N N
Noloop and Slrubenstein 18:46, 6-Aug-2010 13:48, 15-Aug-2010 9 Declined 0 6 0 1 2 C I I N N D D D D D D N N
Designation of existence of historical Jesus as fact … 19:29, 27-Jul-2010 19:36, 29-Jul-2010 2 Declined 0 6 0 0 1 D I N N D D D D D N N
Ethnic Advocacy and Editor COI 12:34, 19-Jul-2010 15:17, 20-Jul-2010 1 Declined 0 5 0 0 3 D D I N N I I D D D N N
Blocking and unblocking 17:47, 11-Jul-2010 02:39, 16-Jul-2010 4 Declined 0 7 0 1 2 D I N N D I D D D D D C N N
Appeal of sanction against Aregakn 23:12, 9-Jun-2010 18:37, 24-Jun-2010 15 Declined 0 5 0 2 3 I I N N C I D C D D D D N N
Stephan Schulz? & Lar 21:14, 20-May-2010 00:30, 13-Jun-2010 23 Declined 1 1 3 4 2 C R C I N N I C C A D R R N N
Climate change 12:43, 25-May-2010 00:30, 13-Jun-2010 18 Accepted 6 0 3 1 2 C R A I N N I A A A A A R R N N
Sock Puppet Standards of Evidence 09:17, 4-Jun-2010 00:28, 13-Jun-2010 9 Declined 0 5 2 1 3 I R D I N N I C D D D D R N N
Race and Intelligence 13:13, 1-Jun-2010 11:29, 7-Jun-2010 6 Accepted 6 0 1 0 3 I A I N N I A R A A A A N N
Attempt to create Wikipedia policy about longevity of citation needed tags … 00:46, 31-May-2010 23:45, 31-May-2010 1 Withdrawn 0 1 0 0 3 I I N N I D N N
Keegscee 20:18, 23-May-2010 17:02, 30-May-2010 7 Declined 0 5 0 2 2 D I N N D I D D C C D N N
Districts of Kosovo in Serbia 21:25, 18-May-2010 21:05, 21-May-2010 3 Declined 0 6 0 0 1 D I N N D D D D D N N
A Nobody 17:06, 17-May-2010 13:16, 20-May-2010 3 Motion 0 2 1 2 1 R C C I N N D D N N
1953 Iranian coup POV 15:34, 27-Apr-2010 16:26, 8-May-2010 11 Declined 4 4 0 1 5 A I A I N I D D I C A A D D I N N
CONMEBOL tables 13:57, 5-May-2010 16:25, 8-May-2010 3 Declined 0 6 0 0 5 D I I N I I D D D D D I N N
Controversial edits to Sharia article ... 13:14, 23-Apr-2010 16:36, 30-Apr-2010 7 Declined 0 6 0 0 2 D N D D I D D D N I
Christ myth theory 14:43, 13-Apr-2010 01:47, 18-Apr-2010 4 Declined 0 9 0 0 1 D D N D I D D D D D D N I
Alastair Haines 2 18:28, 13-Apr-2010 01:23, 18-Apr-2010 4 Accepted 8 0 0 0 1 A A N A I A A A A A N I
COI edits in respect of living individuals 15:47, 27-Mar-2010 13:47, 6-Apr-2010 10 Declined 1 3 1 3 1 D A N C D C C D R N I
Russavia's request for arbitration enforcement concerning Biophys 06:43, 26-Mar-2010 05:04, 6-Apr-2010 11 Accepted 8 1 0 0 1 D A N A A A A A A A N I
Dirty, Dangerous and Demeaning 20:35, 27-Mar-2010 21:40, 30-Mar-2010 3 Declined 0 6 0 0 1 N D D D D D D N I
Enforcement of Climate Change discretionary sanctions 00:49, 17-Mar-2010 21:02, 29-Mar-2010 13 Declined 0 5 1 0 2 D N D I D D D R N I
A Nobody 05:51, 14-Mar-2010 23:26, 19-Mar-2010 6 Accepted 13 0 1 0 2 R A A A N A A A A A I A A A A A N I
WP:OWN in Judaism articles 06:55, 13-Mar-2010 10:19, 16-Mar-2010 3 Declined 0 7 0 0 1 D N D D D D D D N I
Durova and Shoemaker's Holiday 22:04, 9-Mar-2010 04:51, 15-Mar-2010 5 Motion 2 3 4 3 1 R D C N C D C R R A A R D N I
Trusilver's unblock of Brews ohare 06:22, 1-Mar-2010 04:17, 15-Mar-2010 14 Motion 0 0 0 7 1 C C C N C C C C N I
Elizabeth II 08:54, 9-Mar-2010 00:41, 12-Mar-2010 3 Declined 0 8 0 2 2 I C N D D D C D D D D D N I
Malik Shabazz 11:09, 6-Mar-2010 17:38, 11-Mar-2010 5 Declined 0 7 0 4 2 I C N D D D C D C D D C D N I
Gibraltar 12:16, 5-Mar-2010 16:39, 11-Mar-2010 6 Accepted 9 0 2 0 2 I A A N R A A A A R A A A N I
User:Steaphen 13:05, 1-Mar-2010 21:28, 8-Mar-2010 7 Declined 0 8 0 0 3 I N D D D D D D D D N I
Catholic Church 18:09, 22-Feb-2010 18:36, 4-Mar-2010 10 Declined 2 5 2 0 3 I D I N A D D D R R D A N I
Nigam Arora 21:45, 28-Feb-2010 18:35, 4-Mar-2010 4 Declined 0 6 0 1 4 I I N I D D D D C D D N I
Christ myth theory 23:56, 23-Feb-2010 06:12, 2-Mar-2010 6 Declined 0 6 0 1 3 I I N D D D D D D C N I
Bourbon-Two Sicilies 01:09, 19-Feb-2010 16:11, 24-Feb-2010 6 Declined 0 8 0 0 3 I I N D D D D D D D D N I
Pedro II of Brazil 03:01, 20-Feb-2010 16:08, 24-Feb-2010 5 Withdrawn 0 7 0 0 4 I I N I D D D D D D D N I
Ikip 14:25, 17-Feb-2010 16:30, 22-Feb-2010 5 Withdrawn 0 6 2 2 3 I R I N C D D R D D D C D N I
ChildofMidnight 20:11, 15-Feb-2010 04:23, 21-Feb-2010 5 Accepted 6 0 1 3 4 I R A I N I A C C A C A A A N I
Proofreader77 blocks 02:41, 15-Feb-2010 20:13, 20-Feb-2010 6 Declined 1 8 0 0 5 I D I N I D D I A D D D D D N I
Asgardian 21:36, 13-Feb-2010 03:54, 19-Feb-2010 5 Accepted 4 0 0 4 5 I I N I A A I C A C A C C N I
Transcendental Meditation movement 19:15, 15-Feb-2010 10:57, 18-Feb-2010 3 Accepted 9 0 0 1 5 I A I A I A A I A A C A A A N I
Zeno's paradoxes 07:13, 11-Feb-2010 01:12, 14-Feb-2010 3 Declined 0 8 0 0 5 I I I D I D D D D D D D N I
Fringe Theory Ground Rules 14:03, 6-Feb-2010 17:30, 10-Feb-2010 4 Declined 0 8 0 0 5 I I I D I D D D D D D D N I
Defender 911 00:51, 5-Feb-2010 16:10, 5-Feb-2010 1 Withdrawn 0 3 0 0 3 I D I D D N I
Jéské Couriano 22:34, 30-Jan-2010 04:45, 3-Feb-2010 3 Declined 0 6 0 0 3 I I D D D D D D N I
David Irving Biography 16:05, 31-Jan-2010 04:42, 3-Feb-2010 3 Declined 0 7 0 0 3 I I D D D D D D D N I
WP:PROD wheel war 09:16, 23-Jan-2010 12:01, 31-Jan-2010 8 Declined 4 8 0 3 1 A D C I D D D D C D A D D A A N C
Craigy144 18:51, 20-Jan-2010 00:42, 30-Jan-2010 9 Motion 0 3 0 8 2 C D D I C C C C C C D C N I
BLP deletions 01:52, 21-Jan-2010 18:48, 22-Jan-2010 2 Motion 9 1 2 2 0 A R A A A A R C C A D A A N A
Misty Willows 17:45, 21-Jan-2010 03:48, 22-Jan-2010 0 Withdrawn 0 0 0 1 2 I C N I
MZMcBride 2 18:53, 16-Jan-2010 22:53, 19-Jan-2010 3 Accepted 9 2 1 4 1 C R A A A A A A D D C A C A A C I
POV tag at Israel and the apartheid analogy 21:50, 14-Jan-2010 05:06, 18-Jan-2010 3 Declined 0 8 1 0 2 D I D D R D D D D D I
Badagnani 02:30, 12-Jan-2010 17:27, 17-Jan-2010 6 Declined 0 9 0 1 2 C I D D D D D D D D D I
Chabad movement editors 07:17, 5-Jan-2010 07:01, 9-Jan-2010 4 Accepted 8 1 0 0 3 A I A A A I A A A D A I
Character list merge 02:27, 5-Jan-2010 05:18, 7-Jan-2010 2 Declined 0 10 0 0 2 D I D D D D D D D D D I
Climate Change 02:08, 30-Dec-2009 22:59, 5-Jan-2010 7 Declined 1 10 1 2 1 C A D D D D C D D D D D R D I
Climate Change Probation 09:46, 2-Jan-2010 22:56, 5-Jan-2010 4 Declined 0 9 1 0 2 D I D D D D D D D D R I

Requests: 78; average duration: 6.4 days; accepted: 14 (18%); declined: 52 (67%); disposed by motion: 6 (8%); withdrawn: 6 (8%)

Involving 2010 and departing 2009 arbs

[edit]
Case requests involving 2010 and departing 2009 arbs
Request Opened Closed Days Disp A D R C I Car Chl Cor Fay Flo Fri Her Kir Kni Mai New Ris Rle Rog She Sir Ste Sts Vas Wiz

Requests: 0

Clarifications and other requests

[edit]
  • Requests: 89; average duration: 20.3 days; declined: 30 (34%); disposed by clarification: 27 (30%); disposed by motion: 27 (30%); withdrawn: 3 (3%); removed: 2 (2%).

Involving 2010 arbs only

[edit]
Clarifications and other requests involving 2010 arbs only
Request Opened Closed Days Disp R C I Car Chl Cor Fay Fri Her Kir Kni Mai New Ris Rle Rog She Sir Sts Vas Wiz
Amend : Date delinking 20:22, 11-Nov-2010 17:41, 20-Dec-2010 39 Declined 0 6 2 I C I N N C C C N C C N N N
Clarify : Race and intelligence 03:55, 29-Nov-2010 21:37, 17-Dec-2010 19 Motion 1 4 2 I I N N C R N C C C N N N
Clarify : Eastern European mailing list 23:19, 6-Dec-2010 02:54, 10-Dec-2010 3 Clarification 0 4 2 I C I N N C C N C N N N
Clarify : Palestine-Israel articles 08:24, 19-Nov-2010 01:51, 9-Dec-2010 20 Clarification 1 4 2 I I N N C R N C C C N N N
Amend : Russavia-Biophys 15:32, 7-Nov-2010 01:50, 9-Dec-2010 31 Declined 0 6 2 C I I N N C C C N C C N N N
Amend : Russavia-Biophys 14:40, 25-Nov-2010 17:08, 26-Nov-2010 1 Removed 0 2 1 I N N C C N N N N
Amend : Climate change 17:23, 12-Nov-2010 19:13, 23-Nov-2010 11 Declined 0 5 2 C I N N C C C N C I N N
Clarify : Climate change 04:50, 11-Nov-2010 19:11, 23-Nov-2010 13 Clarification 2 5 2 C I C N N C R C N C R I N N
Amend : Kehrli 23:12, 5-Nov-2010 06:56, 21-Nov-2010 15 Declined 0 8 2 C I C N N C C C N C C C I N N
Amend : Speed of light 16:38, 15-Nov-2010 14:51, 18-Nov-2010 3 Motion 0 4 2 C I N N C N C C I N N
Amend : Eastern European mailing list 22:57, 21-Sep-2010 17:07, 13-Nov-2010 53 Motion 2 4 2 C I C N N C N R R C I N N
Clarify : Badlydrawnjeff 21:31, 27-Oct-2010 04:59, 13-Nov-2010 16 Clarification 0 6 2 C I N N C C C N C C I N N
Clarify : Race and intelligence 21:03, 25-Oct-2010 04:58, 13-Nov-2010 18 Clarification 0 5 2 C I C N N C N C C I N N
Clarify : Climate change 20:05, 25-Oct-2010 21:11, 9-Nov-2010 15 Motion 0 0 2 I N N N I N N
Clarify : Climate change 00:15, 24-Oct-2010 21:05, 9-Nov-2010 17 Clarification 0 6 2 C I C N N C C N C C I N N
Clarify : Pseudoscience 21:54, 22-Oct-2010 20:17, 9-Nov-2010 18 Clarification 0 1 2 I N N N C I N N
Amend : Date delinking 06:57, 29-Oct-2010 14:39, 9-Nov-2010 11 Declined 0 2 2 I N N C C I N N
Amend : Franco-Mongol alliance 04:01, 2-Oct-2010 14:47, 8-Nov-2010 37 Motion 0 3 2 C I C N N N C I N N
Clarify DIGWUREN 21:52, 15-Oct-2010 17:32, 7-Nov-2010 23 Clarification 0 4 2 C I N N C C C N I N N
Amend : Eastern European mailing list 09:45, 6-Oct-2010 19:11, 31-Oct-2010 25 Declined 1 2 2 I C N N N R C I N N
Clarify : Speed of light 15:14, 26-Sep-2010 02:54, 21-Oct-2010 24 Clarification 0 3 2 I N N C C C I N N
Clarify : Eastern European mailing list 00:29, 7-Oct-2010 02:54, 21-Oct-2010 14 Clarification 0 2 2 I C N N C I N N
Clarify : Eastern European mailing list 20:41, 16-Oct-2010 02:38, 21-Oct-2010 4 Withdrawn 0 1 2 I N N C I N N
Amend : Eastern European mailing list 09:07, 11-Sep-2010 17:13, 20-Oct-2010 39 Declined 1 4 2 I N N C C C R C I N N
Amend : Koavf 04:32, 15-Oct-2010 17:12, 20-Oct-2010 6 Declined 0 4 2 I N N C C C C I N N
Amend : ChildofMidnight 02:11, 16-Oct-2010 17:12, 20-Oct-2010 5 Declined 0 3 2 I N N C C C I N N
Clarify : Transcendental Meditation movement 20:24, 12-Sep-2010 08:17, 12-Oct-2010 29 Clarification 0 5 3 I C N N C I C C C I N N
Amend : Race and intelligence 06:27, 10-Sep-2010 16:20, 11-Oct-2010 31 Declined 0 5 3 I C N N C I C C C I N N
Amend : ChildofMidnight 09:36, 27-Aug-2010 09:11, 23-Sep-2010 27 Declined 0 7 2 C I C N N C C C C C I N N
Amend : Speed of light 05:40, 29-Aug-2010 08:58, 23-Sep-2010 25 Declined 0 3 3 C I N N C I C I N N
Clarify : Race and intelligence 09:08, 23-Aug-2010 18:03, 5-Sep-2010 13 Clarification 0 7 1 C C N N C C C C C I N N
Amend : Eastern European mailing list 20:58, 7-Jul-2010 17:45, 4-Sep-2010 59 Motion 2 5 2 C I C N N C C R R C I N N
Amend : Tothwolf 06:56, 5-Aug-2010 14:45, 4-Sep-2010 30 Motion 0 5 2 C C N N C I C C I N N
Amend : Date delinking 22:11, 11-Jul-2010 13:45, 4-Sep-2010 55 Motion 2 8 1 R I C N N C C C C C C C R N N
Amend : Fringe science 13:38, 13-Aug-2010 00:53, 28-Aug-2010 14 Declined 3 5 2 C R C I N N C R R C C I N N
Amend : Speed of light 17:01, 11-Aug-2010 16:10, 22-Aug-2010 11 Motion 0 3 2 C I I N N C C N N
Amend : Everyking 3 10:01, 17-Aug-2010 19:25, 19-Aug-2010 2 Declined 0 6 4 C I I I N N C C C C C I N N
Clarify : Speed of light 07:00, 4-Aug-2010 03:12, 12-Aug-2010 8 Clarification 0 3 2 C I N N C I C N N
Amend : Eastern European mailing list 19:58, 21-Jul-2010 03:16, 4-Aug-2010 13 Declined 3 2 2 I N N R C C R R I N N
Clarify User:Betacommand 17:06, 20-Jul-2010 03:09, 4-Aug-2010 14 Clarification 0 4 2 I N N C C C C I N N
Amend : Betacommand 2 15:48, 25-Jul-2010 07:12, 31-Jul-2010 6 Motion 0 1 2 I N N C I N N
Clarify : Ireland article names 08:42, 29-Jun-2010 19:22, 29-Jul-2010 30 Clarification 0 2 1 C I N N C N N
Clarify User:SlimVirgin 00:47, 18-Jul-2010 19:21, 29-Jul-2010 12 Clarification 0 3 1 I N N C C C N N
Clarify : The Troubles 15:27, 20-Jul-2010 19:13, 29-Jul-2010 9 Clarification 0 5 1 C I N N C C C C N N
Amend : Eastern European mailing list 03:04, 27-Jun-2010 01:43, 29-Jul-2010 32 Declined 3 6 2 C I N N R I C C C R R C C N N
Amend : Eastern European mailing list 10:29, 28-Jun-2010 23:55, 20-Jul-2010 23 Motion 2 3 3 I N N I C C I R R C N N
Amend : Ferrylodge 06:22, 22-May-2010 20:12, 7-Jul-2010 47 Withdrawn 1 6 2 C R C I N N I C C C C N N
Amend : Speed of light 18:17, 16-Jun-2010 20:08, 7-Jul-2010 21 Motion 0 3 2 C I N N I C C N N
Amend : Eastern European mailing list 19:53, 21-Jun-2010 19:51, 2-Jul-2010 11 Motion 0 0 2 I N N I N N
Amend : Tothwolf 05:46, 16-May-2010 19:33, 2-Jul-2010 48 Motion 0 5 2 C C I N N I C C C N N
Amend : Pseudoscience 13:09, 15-Jun-2010 19:11, 2-Jul-2010 17 Motion 0 3 2 I N N C I C C N N
Amend : Eastern European mailing list 18:04, 1-Jun-2010 20:55, 21-Jun-2010 20 Motion 1 2 3 I C I N N I C R N N
Clarify Juice Plus 16:22, 17-Jun-2010 10:42, 20-Jun-2010 3 Removed 0 2 3 I I N N I C C N N
Amend : Derek Smart 01:56, 22-Apr-2010 18:29, 9-Jun-2010 49 Declined 1 5 2 I I N N R C C C C C N N
Clarify : Date delinking 07:11, 30-Apr-2010 18:25, 9-Jun-2010 40 Clarification 2 2 2 R C I N N I C R N N
Clarify : Armenia-Azerbaijan 2 16:45, 18-Apr-2010 13:30, 20-May-2010 32 Clarification 0 6 2 C I C I N N C C C C N N
Amend : Franco-Mongol alliance 12:58, 24-Apr-2010 13:23, 20-May-2010 26 Declined 0 5 1 C C C I N N C C N N
Amend : Eastern European mailing list 21:34, 15-Apr-2010 00:43, 6-May-2010 20 Motion 1 6 6 C I C I N I C I C C R C I N I
Clarify : Tang Dynasty 20:31, 18-Feb-2010 15:23, 4-May-2010 75 Motion 0 7 4 C I C I N C I C C C C N I
Clarify User:Sulmues 20:35, 15-Apr-2010 10:33, 2-May-2010 17 Clarification 0 5 6 C I I N I I C C C C I N I
Amend : Franco-Mongol alliance 20:27, 13-Apr-2010 16:32, 22-Apr-2010 9 Declined 1 4 2 C N I C C R C N I
Clarify ban of User:Offliner 10:43, 11-Apr-2010 02:09, 14-Apr-2010 3 Clarification 0 5 1 C C N C C C N I
Clarify : Motion regarding biographies of living people deletions 08:27, 7-Mar-2010 19:20, 7-Apr-2010 31 Clarification 1 6 1 C C N C R C C C N I
Clarify : Abd-William M. Connolley 16:04, 16-Mar-2010 19:18, 7-Apr-2010 22 Clarification 1 3 1 C N C C R N I
Amend : Scientology 22:01, 12-Mar-2010 21:30, 30-Mar-2010 18 Declined 0 5 2 C C C N I C C N I
Amend : Franco-Mongol alliance 07:33, 16-Feb-2010 20:39, 30-Mar-2010 43 Motion 2 4 2 C C N R C I R C N I
Amend : Asmahan 13:09, 20-Feb-2010 12:14, 26-Mar-2010 34 Declined 0 3 2 C N I C C N I
Amend : Falun Gong 04:34, 23-Feb-2010 03:31, 13-Mar-2010 18 Declined 0 4 1 C N C C C N I
Clarify : Ireland article names 17:42, 21-Feb-2010 01:12, 12-Mar-2010 18 Clarification 1 4 2 I N C C C C R N I
Clarify : Abd-William M. Connolley 21:08, 27-Feb-2010 05:15, 10-Mar-2010 10 Withdrawn 1 5 2 I C N C C C C R N I
Clarify : Ireland article names 19:07, 17-Feb-2010 16:03, 5-Mar-2010 16 Motion 2 3 4 I C I N I C C R R N I
Amend : Footnoted quotes 07:42, 14-Feb-2010 14:35, 2-Mar-2010 16 Declined 1 5 4 I C I N I C C R C C N I
Amend : Speed of light 05:02, 8-Feb-2010 14:32, 2-Mar-2010 22 Declined 0 7 4 I C I N I C C C C C C N I
Clarify : C68-FM-SV 00:00, 12-Feb-2010 19:02, 14-Feb-2010 3 Clarification 0 4 6 I I I I I C C C C N I
Amend : Eastern European mailing list 03:32, 28-Jan-2010 18:21, 13-Feb-2010 17 Motion 0 1 4 C I I I N I
Amend : Ryulong 08:46, 21-Jan-2010 17:56, 3-Feb-2010 13 Declined 2 9 2 C C I C R C C R C C C C N I
Clarify : Abd-William M. Connolley 09:11, 11-Jan-2010 23:49, 2-Feb-2010 23 Motion 5 2 2 R I R R C C R R N I
Amend : Eastern European mailing list 08:42, 22-Jan-2010 11:12, 28-Jan-2010 6 Motion 1 3 2 C I C R C N I
Amend : Eastern European mailing list 06:23, 23-Jan-2010 11:11, 28-Jan-2010 5 Motion 0 1 2 I C N I
Amend : Speed of light 20:12, 13-Jan-2010 02:06, 27-Jan-2010 13 Motion 0 5 2 C I C C C C I
Amend : Falun Gong 22:02, 14-Jan-2010 07:18, 19-Jan-2010 4 Motion 1 1 2 I C R I
Amend : Asmahan 18:08, 3-Jan-2010 07:11, 19-Jan-2010 16 Declined 0 4 2 C I C C C I
Amend : September 11 conspiracy theories 09:46, 4-Jan-2010 07:08, 19-Jan-2010 15 Declined 1 8 2 C I C C R C C C C C I
Clarify : Eastern European mailing list 21:55, 31-Dec-2009 07:05, 19-Jan-2010 18 Clarification 0 10 2 C I C C C C C C C C C I
Clarify : Eastern European mailing list 01:28, 1-Jan-2010 07:03, 19-Jan-2010 18 Clarification 1 11 1 C C C C C C C C R C C C I
Amend : Asmahan 19:26, 23-Dec-2009 18:08, 10-Jan-2010 18 Declined 0 6 3 C I C I C C C C I
Amend : Obama articles 01:11, 1-Jan-2010 17:57, 10-Jan-2010 10 Declined 0 5 3 C I C I C C C I
Amend : West Bank - Judea and Samaria 20:43, 29-Dec-2009 17:54, 10-Jan-2010 12 Declined 0 7 2 C C I C C C C C I
Clarify : Abd-William M. Connolley 00:56, 1-Jan-2010 16:04, 10-Jan-2010 10 Motion 0 3 3 I C C I C I

Requests: 89; average duration: 20.3 days; declined: 30 (34%); disposed by clarification: 27 (30%); disposed by motion: 27 (30%); withdrawn: 3 (3%); removed: 2 (2%)

Involving 2010 and departing 2009 arbs

[edit]
Clarifications and other requests involving 2010 and departing 2009 arbs
Request Opened Closed Days Disp R C I Car Chl Cor Fay Flo Fri Her Kir Kni Mai New Ris Rle Rog She Sir Ste Sts Vas Wiz

Requests: 0

Arb activity

[edit]

Legend

[edit]

The following two tables each contain three sections, the first covering case requests, the second other requests and the third all requests. The column headings have the following meanings:

  • ER (eligible requests): Indicates the beginning of a new section and gives the total number respectively, of case requests, other requests, or all requests, for which this arb was eligible to act (count of non-"N"s).
  • I (inactive): The total number of requests for which this arb was listed at Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee as inactive/away at the time of the request's closing, and did not act on the request (i.e. did not recuse. accept, decline or comment) (count of "I"s); as a percentage of ER.
  • R (recused): The total number of requests for which this arb recused (count of "R"s); as a percentage of (ER − I).
  • V (voted): The total number of case requests this arb voted to accept or decline (count of "A"s or "D"s); as a percentage of (ER − (I + R)).
  • DNA (did not act): The total number of requests for which this arb was listed at Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee as active at the time of the request's closing, but did not act (count of empty cells); as a percentage of (ER − (I + R)).
  • A (accept): The total number of case requests this arb voted to accept (count of "A"s); as a percentage of V.
  • D (decline): The total number of case requests this arb voted to decline (count of "D"s); as a percentage of V.
  • C (comment): The total number of other requests this arb commented on (count of "C"s); as a percentage of (ER − (I + R)).

Arb activity (2010)

[edit]
Arb activity (2010) — requests
Arb ER I % R % V % DNA % A % D % ER I % R % C % DNA % ER I % R % DNA %
Carcharoth 78 22 28% 4 7% 33 63% 11 21% 6 18% 27 82% 89 9 10% 2 3% 46 59% 32 41% 167 31 19% 6 4% 43 33%
Cool Hand Luke 78 23 29% 7 13% 7 15% 40 83% 2 29% 5 71% 89 37 42% 3 6% 11 22% 38 78% 167 60 36% 10 9% 78 80%
Coren 78 12 15% 0 0% 29 44% 32 48% 18 62% 11 38% 89 16 18% 0 0% 32 44% 41 56% 167 28 17% 0 0% 73 53%
FayssalF 78 38 49% 0 0% 4 10% 32 80% 3 75% 1 25% 89 36 40% 1 2% 0 0% 52 100% 167 74 44% 1 1% 84 91%
Fritzpoll 17 0 0% 0 0% 12 71% 4 24% 4 33% 8 67% 16 0 0% 1 6% 4 27% 11 73% 33 0 0% 1 3% 15 47%
Hersfold 43 10 23% 0 0% 15 45% 16 48% 5 33% 10 67% 32 7 22% 1 4% 6 25% 18 75% 75 17 23% 1 2% 34 60%
Kirill Lokshin 78 0 0% 3 4% 33 44% 40 53% 7 21% 26 79% 89 0 0% 4 4% 32 38% 53 62% 167 0 0% 7 4% 93 58%
KnightLago 78 8 10% 0 0% 47 67% 21 30% 12 26% 35 74% 89 10 11% 0 0% 7 9% 72 91% 167 18 11% 0 0% 93 62%
Mailer diablo 78 9 12% 1 1% 28 41% 40 59% 4 14% 24 86% 89 6 7% 1 1% 6 7% 76 93% 167 15 9% 2 1% 116 77%
Newyorkbrad 78 1 1% 1 1% 43 57% 16 21% 11 26% 32 74% 89 4 4% 3 4% 43 52% 39 48% 167 5 3% 4 2% 55 35%
Risker 78 2 3% 5 7% 37 52% 29 41% 8 22% 29 78% 89 3 3% 3 3% 27 33% 56 67% 167 5 3% 8 5% 85 55%
Rlevse 66 6 9% 1 2% 38 64% 17 29% 12 32% 26 68% 70 5 7% 2 3% 26 41% 37 59% 136 11 8% 3 2% 54 44%
Roger Davies 78 0 0% 3 4% 32 43% 39 52% 7 22% 25 78% 89 0 0% 6 7% 21 25% 62 75% 167 0 0% 9 5% 101 64%
Shell Kinney 78 3 4% 1 1% 43 58% 24 32% 14 33% 29 67% 89 1 1% 13 15% 41 55% 34 45% 167 4 2% 14 9% 58 39%
SirFozzie 78 0 0% 3 4% 62 83% 9 12% 17 27% 45 73% 89 3 3% 2 2% 46 55% 38 45% 167 3 2% 5 3% 47 30%
Steve Smith 69 12 17% 8 14% 37 76% 8 16% 10 27% 27 73% 83 30 36% 7 13% 24 52% 22 48% 152 42 28% 15 14% 30 32%
Vassyana 7 0 0% 0 0% 5 71% 1 14% 1 20% 4 80% 10 0 0% 1 10% 9 100% 0 0% 17 0 0% 1 6% 1 6%
Wizardman 41 39 95% 0 0% 1 50% 0 0% 1 100% 0 0% 32 32 100% 0 0 0 73 71 97% 0 0% 0 0%
Case requests Clarifications and other requests All requests

Arb activity (departing 2009)

[edit]
Arb activity (departing 2009) — requests
Arb ER I % R % V % DNA % A % D % ER I % R % C % DNA % ER I % R % DNA %
FloNight 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Stephen Bain 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Case requests Clarifications and other requests All requests

Motions

[edit]
  • Legend: S=Support, O=Oppose, A=Abstain, Ac=Active arbs, R=Recuse, I=Inactive/away, M=Majority, N=Not eligible, Offered = the arb who posted the motion.
  • Publicly offered motions: 60; average duration: 7.4 days; passed: 48 (80%); failed: 12 (20%).
Motions involving 2010 arbs only
Motion Per Request Opened Closed Days Disp S O A Ac R I M Car Chl Cor Fay Fri Her Kir Kni Mai New Ris Rle Rog She Sir Sts Vas Wiz Offered
Motion 1 YellowMonkey 01:09, 20-Dec-2010 21:16, 24-Dec-2010 5 Failed 3 5 0 11 0 1 6 O O S I N N O O S N O S N N N Sir
Motion 2 YellowMonkey 04:13, 20-Dec-2010 21:16, 24-Dec-2010 5 Passed 8 2 0 11 0 1 6 S S O I N N S S S S S N S O N N N Car
Remedy 6 terminated Clarify : Race and intelligence 10:08, 15-Dec-2010 21:37, 17-Dec-2010 2 Passed 6 0 0 9 1 2 5 S I S I N N S R N S S S N N N Rog
Brews ohare banned for one year Amend : Speed of light 21:25, 15-Nov-2010 14:51, 18-Nov-2010 3 Passed 8 1 0 11 0 2 6 O I S N N S S S S S N S S I N N Kir
Piotrus topic ban narrowed Amend : Eastern European mailing list (2) 13:49, 5-Nov-2010 17:07, 13-Nov-2010 8 Passed 5 0 0 8 3 2 5 S I S N N R S S N R R S I N N Cor
Climate change "Scope of topic bans" amemded Clarify : Climate change (2) 16:10, 2-Nov-2010 21:11, 9-Nov-2010 7 Passed 9 0 0 11 0 2 6 S I S S N N S S S S N S S I N N Rog
Climate change "Appeal of topic bans" amemded Clarify : Climate change (2) 16:10, 2-Nov-2010 21:11, 9-Nov-2010 7 Passed 8 0 1 11 0 2 6 S I S A N N S S S S N S S I N N Rog
Marknutley and William M.Connolley unblocked Clarify : Climate change (2) 16:10, 2-Nov-2010 21:11, 9-Nov-2010 7 Failed 3 4 2 11 0 2 5 O I O S N N O O S A N S A I N N Rog
Ohconfucius permitted to use automation Amend : Date delinking 21:00, 30-Oct-2010 14:39, 9-Nov-2010 10 Passed 7 0 0 11 1 2 6 R I S N N S S S S S S I N N Kir
Per Honor et Gloria topic ban extended indefinitely Amend : Franco-Mongol alliance 04:01, 2-Oct-2010 14:47, 8-Nov-2010 37 Passed 6 0 0 10 1 2 6 S I S N N S S N S R S I N N Sir
Martintg topic ban lifted Amend : Eastern European Mailing List (4) 23:57, 27-Aug-2010 17:45, 4-Sep-2010 8 Failed 1 6 0 10 2 2 6 S I O N N O O O O O R R I N N Car
Martintg topic ban modified Amend : Eastern European Mailing List (4) 01:25, 28-Aug-2010 17:45, 4-Sep-2010 8 Passed 9 0 0 10 1 3 6 S I S N N S S S S S S R I S I N N New
Tothwolf, Miami33139, JBSupreme are banned from interacting Amend : Tothwolf 10:44, 24-Aug-2010 14:45, 4-Sep-2010 11 Passed 10 0 0 12 0 2 7 S I S N N S S S S S S S S I N N She
Miami33139 editing restriction Amend : Tothwolf 10:44, 24-Aug-2010 14:45, 4-Sep-2010 11 Passed 9 0 1 12 0 2 6 S I S N N S S S A S S S S I N N She
JBsupreme editing restriction Amend : Tothwolf 10:44, 24-Aug-2010 14:45, 4-Sep-2010 11 Passed 8 0 1 12 0 2 6 S I S N N S S S A S S S I N N She
Lightmouse is permitted to use automation as authorized Amend : Date delinking 21:23, 24-Aug-2010 13:45, 4-Sep-2010 11 Failed 4 4 0 11 2 1 6 R I O N N S O S O S S O R N N Kir
Lightmouse is permitted a one authorized automated task Amend : Date delinking 15:36, 29-Aug-2010 13:45, 4-Sep-2010 6 Passed 8 0 0 11 2 1 6 R I S N N S S S S S S S R N N Cor
Brews ohare indefinite general probation Amend : Speed of light 02:07, 11-Aug-2010 16:10, 22-Aug-2010 12 Failed 4 5 0 12 0 2 7 O O I I N N S O S S O S O N N Kir
Brews ohare topic banned from all physics pages Amend : Speed of light 02:07, 11-Aug-2010 16:10, 22-Aug-2010 12 Passed 9 0 0 12 0 2 7 S S I I N N S S S S S S S N N Sts
Betacommand authorized to operate bot for specific task Amend : Betacommand 2 19:15, 29-Jul-2010 07:12, 31-Jul-2010 1 Passed 7 1 0 12 1 1 7 R S I N N S S S O S S S N N Rog
Betacommand authorized to operate bot Amend : Betacommand 2 17:26, 25-Jul-2010 07:12, 31-Jul-2010 6 Failed 4 3 0 12 1 1 7 R O I N N S S O O S S N N Kir
Miacek topic ban lifted Amend : Eastern European mailing list (3) 15:47, 5-Jul-2010 23:55, 20-Jul-2010 15 Passed 8 0 0 9 2 3 5 S S I N N S I I S S S R R S S N N Sts
Amendment 4 expires concurrently with remedy 4.2 Amend : Speed of light 14:11, 24-Jun-2010 20:08, 7-Jul-2010 13 Passed 7 0 0 12 0 2 7 S S I N N S I S S S S N N Sts
Biruitorul topic banned lifted Amend : Eastern European mailing list 14:07, 24-Jun-2010 19:51, 2-Jul-2010 8 Passed 6 0 0 9 2 3 5 I S S I N N R I S S R S S N N Sts
Remedy 2 changed Amend : Tothwolf 20:26, 19-Jun-2010 19:33, 2-Jul-2010 13 Passed 7 0 0 11 0 3 6 I S S I N N S I S S S S N N Rle
The words "such as Time Cube" are struck Amend : Pseudoscience 22:59, 17-Jun-2010 19:11, 2-Jul-2010 15 Passed 7 0 2 11 0 3 5 I A S I N N S I S S S S A S N N Sts
Radeksz topic banned lifted Amend : Eastern European mailing list 04:49, 9-Jun-2010 20:55, 21-Jun-2010 13 Passed 7 0 0 8 3 3 5 I S S I N N R I S S S S R R S N N Sts
Piotrus editing restriction amended Amend : Eastern European mailing list 18:40, 27-Apr-2010 00:43, 6-May-2010 8 Passed 6 1 0 8 2 6 5 S I S I N I R S I S O S R S I N I Cor
Tenmei Clarify : Tang Dynasty 17:44, 27-Apr-2010 15:23, 4-May-2010 7 Passed 8 1 0 10 0 6 6 S I S I N I S S I S S S S O I N I Ris
Altenmann - Removal of administrator permissions 20:51, 10-Apr-2010 01:08, 13-Apr-2010 2 Passed 13 0 0 15 1 0 8 S S S N S S S S S S S S S R N S Ris
1. PHG's mentorship is renewed Amend : Franco-Mongol alliance 22:56, 20-Mar-2010 20:39, 30-Mar-2010 10 Passed 7 0 0 12 2 2 7 S S S N R S I S R S S N I Chl
2. PHG's topic ban is renewed Amend : Franco-Mongol alliance 22:56, 20-Mar-2010 20:39, 30-Mar-2010 10 Passed 7 0 0 12 2 2 7 S S S N R S I S R S S N I Chl
2.1 PHG new article restriction Amend : Franco-Mongol alliance 07:56, 21-Mar-2010 20:39, 30-Mar-2010 10 Failed 1 5 1 12 2 2 6 O A O N R O I O R O S N I Sir
1. Brews ohare topic ban modified 23:53, 23-Mar-2010 20:13, 29-Mar-2010 6 Passed 10 1 0 14 0 2 8 S O S N S S S I S S S S S N I Sir
1.1 Brews ohare topic ban modified 18:14, 24-Mar-2010 20:13, 29-Mar-2010 5 Failed 3 4 0 14 0 2 8 O S N O I S O O S N I Chl
1.2 Brews ohare topic ban modified 19:34, 25-Mar-2010 20:13, 29-Mar-2010 4 Failed 3 3 0 14 0 2 8 S N S O I O O S N I Chl
2. Brews ohare advocacy restrictions 23:53, 23-Mar-2010 20:13, 29-Mar-2010 6 Passed 8 3 1 14 0 2 7 S O S N A S O O I S S S S S N I Sir
Case accepted not opened A Nobody 18:28, 16-Mar-2010 23:26, 19-Mar-2010 3 Passed 13 0 0 13 1 2 7 R S S S N S S S S S I S S S S S N I Sts
Shoemaker's Holiday and Durova Durova and Shoemaker's Holiday 03:52, 12-Mar-2010 04:51, 15-Mar-2010 3 Passed 8 0 1 10 5 1 5 R S S N S R S A S R R S S R S N I Rog
1) Trusilver/Brews ohare unblock Trusilver's unblock of Brews ohare 20:06, 7-Mar-2010 04:17, 15-Mar-2010 7 Passed 10 5 0 15 0 1 8 O O S O N S S S S O O S S S S S N I Sir
1.1. Trusilver admonished and warned Trusilver's unblock of Brews ohare 17:55, 12-Mar-2010 04:17, 15-Mar-2010 2 Failed* 10 3 2 15 0 1 7 S S S S N O O S S S S O S A A S N I Chl
ArbCom Enforcement Trusilver's unblock of Brews ohare 16:31, 12-Mar-2010 04:17, 15-Mar-2010 2 Passed 13 0 0 15 0 1 8 S S S S N S S S S S S S S S N I Sir
1) Remedy 4 is in force until September 18, 2011 Clarify : Ireland article names 03:36, 23-Feb-2010 16:03, 5-Mar-2010 11 Passed 8 0 0 10 2 4 6 I S I N I S S S S S S S R R N I Cor
2) De facto consensus noted Clarify : Ireland article names 03:36, 23-Feb-2010 16:03, 5-Mar-2010 11 Passed 8 0 0 10 2 4 6 I S I N I S S S S S S S R R N I Cor
1) Herostratus strongly admonished 02:59, 3-Mar-2010 15:15, 5-Mar-2010 3 Passed 10 0 0 13 0 3 7 I S I N S S S S S S S S S N I Her
1.1) Herostratus desysopped 02:59, 3-Mar-2010 15:15, 5-Mar-2010 3 Failed 2 8 0 13 0 3 7 I O I N S O O O O O O O S N I Her
1.2) Herostratus temporarily desysopped 02:59, 3-Mar-2010 15:15, 5-Mar-2010 3 Failed 0 9 0 13 0 3 7 I O I N O O O O O O O O N I Her
2) Viridae admonished 02:59, 3-Mar-2010 15:15, 5-Mar-2010 3 Passed 9 1 0 13 0 3 7 I S I N S S S O S S S S S N I Her
1) Topic ban narrowed (Radeksz) Amend : Eastern European mailing list (3) 23:27, 9-Feb-2010 18:21, 13-Feb-2010 4 Passed 7 0 1 10 2 5 5 I S I I S I S S S S A R R S N I Sts
2) Topic ban narrowed (Martintg) Amend : Eastern European mailing list (3) 23:27, 9-Feb-2010 18:21, 13-Feb-2010 4 Passed 7 0 1 10 2 5 5 I S I I S I S S S S A R R S N I Sts
Abd and William M. Connolley prohibited from interacting Clarify : Abd-William M. Connolley 02:19, 19-Jan-2010 23:49, 2-Feb-2010 15 Passed 6 0 1 10 5 2 5 S R I R R S S S A S R S R N I Kir
Craigy144 desysopped Craigy144 17:40, 28-Jan-2010 20:42, 30-Jan-2010 2 Passed 11 0 0 14 0 3 8 S S I I S S S S S S S S S N I Rog
1) Topic ban narrowed Amend : Eastern European mailing list 21:19, 25-Jan-2010 11:12, 28-Jan-2010 3 Passed 9 0 0 14 1 2 8 S I S S S S S S R S S N I Sts
2) Tagging and categorizing of unreferenced Poland-related BLPs allowed Amend : Eastern European mailing list 21:19, 25-Jan-2010 11:12, 28-Jan-2010 3 Passed 9 0 0 14 1 2 8 S I S S S S S S R S S N I Sts
Proxy authorization Amend : Eastern European mailing list (2) 07:50, 23-Jan-2010 11:11, 28-Jan-2010 5 Passed 8 1 0 15 1 1 8 S S S S S S S O R S N I Kir
1) Exception to topic ban Amend : Speed of light 02:31, 19-Jan-2010 02:06, 27-Jan-2010 8 Passed 9 0 0 15 0 2 8 S I S S S S S S S S N I Kir
2) Second exception to topic ban Amend : Speed of light 18:23, 22-Jan-2010 02:06, 27-Jan-2010 4 Passed 8 0 0 15 0 2 8 S I S S S S S S S N I Ris
Summary motion in lieu of a full case BLP deletions 07:57, 21-Jan-2010 18:48, 22-Jan-2010 1 Passed 9 4 1 15 2 0 8 O R S S S S S R A S O S S O O N S Kir
Imposition of discretionary sanctions Amend : Falun Gong 14:28, 15-Jan-2010 07:18, 19-Jan-2010 4 Passed 9 0 0 16 0 2 9 S I S S S S S S S S I Kir
Remedy 3.2 revised Clarify : Abd-William M. Connolley 10:57, 1-Jan-2010 16:04, 10-Jan-2010 9 Passed 9 0 0 13 2 3 7 S I R S S S I S S S S R S I Vas
  • Failed*: Although receiving enough supports to pass, the motion failed in favor of an alternative motion.


Arb activity

[edit]

The column headings, in table below, have the following meanings:

  • EM (eligible motions): The total number of motions for which this arb was eligible to act (count of non-"N"s).
  • I (inactive): The total number of motions for which this arb was listed at Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee as inactive/away at the time of the motion's closing, and did not act on the motion (i.e. did not recuse. support, oppose or abstain) (count of "I"s); as a percentage of EM.
  • R (recused): The total number of motions for which this arb recused (count of "R"s); as a percentage of (EM − I).
  • V (voted): The total number of motions this arb voted to support or oppose (count of "S"s or "O"s); as a percentage of (EM − (I + R)).
  • A (abstained): The total number of motions for which this arb abstained (count of "A"s), as a percentage of (EM − (I + R)).
  • DNA (did not act): The total number of motions for which this arb was listed at Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee as active at the time of the motion's closing, but did not act (count of empty cells); as a percentage of (EM − (I + R)).
  • S (supported): The total number of motions this arb supported (count of "S"s); as a percentage of V.
  • O (opposed): The total number of motions this arb opposed (count of "O"s); as a percentage of V.
  • Offered: The total number of motions which this arb offered; as a percentage of the total number of motions.
Arb activity (2010) — motions
Arb EM I % R % V % A % DNA % S % O % Offered %
Carcharoth 60 12 20% 7 15% 39 95% 0 0% 2 5% 31 79% 8 21% 2 3%
Cool Hand Luke 60 17 28% 2 5% 25 61% 2 5% 14 34% 19 76% 6 24% 5 8%
Coren 60 12 20% 0 0% 43 90% 0 0% 5 10% 36 84% 7 16% 5 8%
FayssalF 60 24 40% 1 3% 7 20% 1 3% 27 77% 6 86% 1 14% 0 0%
Fritzpoll 12 0 0% 2 17% 6 60% 0 0% 4 40% 6 100% 0 0% 0 0%
Hersfold 33 6 18% 0 0% 16 59% 1 4% 10 37% 14 88% 2 13% 4 7%
Kirill Lokshin 60 0 0% 8 13% 42 81% 0 0% 10 19% 38 90% 4 10% 10 17%
KnightLago 60 6 10% 0 0% 41 76% 0 0% 13 24% 35 85% 6 15% 0 0%
Mailer diablo 60 3 5% 1 2% 37 66% 1 2% 18 32% 30 81% 7 19% 0 0%
Newyorkbrad 60 1 2% 0 0% 43 73% 4 7% 12 20% 37 86% 6 14% 1 2%
Risker 60 8 13% 2 4% 31 62% 3 6% 16 32% 26 84% 5 16% 3 5%
Rlevse 51 0 0% 1 2% 37 74% 0 0% 13 26% 27 73% 10 27% 1 2%
Roger Davies 60 0 0% 11 18% 39 80% 0 0% 10 20% 34 87% 5 13% 7 12%
Shell Kinney 60 1 2% 12 20% 33 70% 2 4% 12 26% 29 88% 4 12% 3 5%
SirFozzie 60 0 0% 3 5% 45 79% 2 4% 10 18% 38 84% 7 16% 7 12%
Steve Smith 57 14 25% 7 16% 29 81% 0 0% 7 19% 27 93% 2 7% 11 18%
Vassyana 2 0 0% 0 0% 1 50% 0 0% 1 50% 1 100% 0 0% 1 2%
Wizardman 33 31 94% 0 0% 2 100% 0 0% 0 0% 2 100% 0 0% 0 0%

Cases

[edit]
  • Legend: Ac=Active, R=Recused, I=Inactive/away, M=Majority, N=Not eligible, Drafter = the poster of the first draft on the case's "Proposed decision" page.
  • Publicly heard cases: 12; average duration: 55 days; decided: 12 (100%); dismissed: 0 (0%).

Involving 2010 arbs only

[edit]
Publicly heard cases involving 2010 arbs only
Case Opened Closed Days Disp Ac R I M Car Chl Cor Fay Fri Her Kir Kni Mai New Ris Rle Rog She Sir Sts Vas Wiz Drafter
Stevertigo 2 29-Sep-2010 23-Oct-2010 24 Decided 12 0 2 7 I N N I N N Kir
Climate change 13-Jun-2010 14-Oct-2010 123 Decided 8 3 3 5 R I N N I I R R N N New
Race and intelligence 7-Jun-2010 24-Aug-2010 78 Decided 10 2 2 6 I N N I R R N N Cor
Transcendental Meditation movement 18-Feb-2010 6-Jun-2010 108 Decided 11 0 3 6 I I N N I N N Rog
Russavia-Biophys 6-Apr-2010 23-May-2010 47 Decided 9 0 5 5 I I N N I I I N N She
Gibraltar 11-Mar-2010 11-May-2010 61 Decided 8 2 5 5 I I N I R I R I N N New
Alastair Haines 2 18-Apr-2010 8-May-2010 20 Decided 10 0 5 6 I I N I I I N N New
Asgardian 19-Feb-2010 10-Apr-2010 50 Decided 14 0 2 8 N I N I Kni
ChildofMidnight 21-Feb-2010 9-Mar-2010 16 Decided 11 1 4 6 I R I N I N I Cor
Chabad movement 9-Jan-2010 13-Feb-2010 35 Decided 12 0 5 7 I I I I N I New
MZMcBride 2 19-Jan-2010 11-Feb-2010 23 Decided 12 1 4 7 I R I I N I Rog

Involving 2010 and departing 2009 arbs

[edit]
Publicly heard cases Involving 2010 and departing 2009 arbs
Case Opened Closed Days Disp Ac R I M Car Chl Cor Fay Fri Her Kir Kni Mai New Ris Rle Rog She Sir Ste Sts Vas Wiz Drafter
Tothwolf 15-Nov-2009 25-Jan-2010 71 Decided 9 0 10 5 I I I I I I I I I I Ste

Arb activity

[edit]

Legend

[edit]

The column headings, in the two tables below, have the following meanings:

  • EC (eligible cases): The total number of cases for which this arb was eligible to act (count of non-"N"s).
  • Inactive: The total number of cases for which this arb was listed on the case's "Proposed decision" talk page as inactive/away (count of empty cells); as a percentage of EC.
  • Recused: The total number of cases for which this arb was listed on the case's "Proposed decision" talk page as recused (count of "R"s); as a percentage of (EC − Inactive).
  • Drafted: The total number of cases for which this arb posted the first draft of the case's "Proposed decision" page; as a percentage of the total number of cases decided.

Arb activity (2010)

[edit]
Arb activity (2010) — cases
Arb EC Inactive % Recused % Drafted %
Carcharoth 12 4 33% 0 0% 0 0%
Cool Hand Luke 12 5 42% 3 43% 0 0%
Coren 12 1 8% 0 0% 2 17%
FayssalF 12 10 83% 0 0% 0 0%
Fritzpoll 3 1 33% 0 0% 0 0%
Hersfold 7 5 71% 0 0% 0 0%
Kirill Lokshin 12 1 8% 1 9% 1 8%
KnightLago 12 4 33% 0 0% 1 8%
Mailer diablo 12 3 25% 0 0% 0 0%
Newyorkbrad 12 0 0% 0 0% 4 33%
Risker 12 2 17% 1 10% 0 0%
Rlevse 12 2 17% 0 0% 0 0%
Roger Davies 12 0 0% 1 8% 2 17%
Shell Kinney 12 1 8% 0 0% 1 8%
SirFozzie 12 0 0% 1 8% 0 0%
Steve Smith 12 6 50% 2 33% 0 0%
Vassyana 1 0 0% 0 0% 0 0%
Wizardman 5 5 100% 0 0 0%

Arb activity (departing 2009)

[edit]
Arb activity (departing 2009) — cases
Arb EC Inactive % Recused % Drafted %
FloNight 0 0 0 0 0%
Stephen Bain 1 0 0% 0 0% 1 8%

Proposals

[edit]
  • Legend: S=Support, O=Oppose, A=Abstain, Ac=Active, R=Recused, I=Inactive/away, M=Majority, N=Not eligible. An "S1" indicates the first supporting vote. The numbers in the second set of arb columns give the length of time (rounded to the nearest day) between the first action (support, oppose or abstain) on this proposal and this arb's action.
  • Proposals: 370; passed: 287 (78%); failed: 83 (22%).

For cases involving 2010 arbs only

[edit]
Case proposals for cases involving 2010 arbs only
Stevertigo 2 - Proposals (AC=12, R=0, I=2) Disp S O A M Car Chl Cor Fay Fri Her Kir Kni Mai New Ris Rle Rog She Sir Sts Vas Wiz Car Chl Cor Fay Fri Her Kir Kni Mai New Ris Rle Rog She Sir Sts Vas Wiz
Verifiability, reliable sources, and original research P1 Passed 11 0 0 7 S I S S N N S1 S S S S S S S I N N 0 0 1 0 1 0 2 0 0 1 0
Accuracy of sourcing P1A Passed 10 0 0 7 S I S S N N S S S1 S S S S I N N 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 0 1 0
Edit-warring P2 Passed 11 0 0 7 S I S S N N S1 S S S S S S S I N N 0 0 1 0 1 0 2 0 0 1 0
Violation of policy P3 Passed 10 0 1 6 S I S A N N S1 S S S S S S S I N N 0 0 1 0 1 0 2 0 0 1 0
Recidivism P4 Passed 11 0 0 7 S I S S N N S1 S S S S S S S I N N 0 0 1 0 1 0 2 0 0 1 0
Previous sanctions F1 Passed 11 0 0 7 S I S S N N S1 S S S S S S S I N N 0 0 1 0 1 0 2 0 0 1 0
Stevertigo's editing F2 Passed 11 0 0 7 S I S S N N S1 S S S S S S S I N N 0 0 1 0 1 0 2 0 0 1 0
Stevertigo's edit summaries F3 Passed 9 0 2 6 S I S A N N S1 A S S S S S S I N N 0 0 1 0 1 0 2 0 0 1 0
Stevertigo's use of sources F4 Passed 11 0 0 7 S I S S N N S1 S S S S S S S I N N 0 0 1 0 1 0 1 0 0 1 0
Stevertigo's approach F5 Passed 11 0 0 7 S I S S N N S1 S S S S S S S I N N 0 0 1 0 1 0 2 0 0 1 0
"Conceptualization" F6 Failed 5 6 0 7 O I S O N N S1 O O O S S O S I N N 0 0 1 0 1 1 2 0 0 1 0
Stevertigo banned R1 Passed 10 1 0 7 O I S S N N S1 S S S S S S S I N N 0 0 2 0 1 0 2 0 0 1 0
Stevertigo to be placed on probation R2 Passed 11 0 0 7 S I S S N N S1 S S S S S S S I N N 0 0 2 0 1 0 2 0 0 1 0
Stevertigo required to cite sources R3 Passed 11 0 0 7 S I S S N N S1 S S S S S S S I N N 0 0 2 0 1 0 2 0 0 1 0
Climate change - Proposals (AC=8, R=3, I=3) Disp S O A M Car Chl Cor Fay Fri Her Kir Kni Mai New Ris Rle Rog She Sir Sts Vas Wiz Car Chl Cor Fay Fri Her Kir Kni Mai New Ris Rle Rog She Sir Sts Vas Wiz
Purpose of Wikipedia P1 Passed 8 0 0 5 S R S I N N S I S S1 S I S S R R N N 24 14 13 30 0 13 19 14
Role of the Arbitration Committee P2 Passed 8 0 0 5 S R S I N N S I S S1 S I S S R R N N 24 14 13 30 0 13 19 14
User Conduct P3 Passed 8 0 0 5 S R S I N N S I S S1 S I S S R R N N 24 14 13 30 0 13 19 14
Collective behavior of blocs of editors P4 Passed 7 0 1 4 S R A I N N S I S S1 S I S S R R N N 24 14 13 30 0 13 19 14
Collective behavior of blocs of editors (alternate) P4.1 Failed* 5 0 1 4 S R S1 I N N S I A S I S R R N N 9 0 0 0 20 5
Wikipedia is not a battleground P5 Passed 8 0 0 5 S R S I N N S I S S1 S I S S R R N N 24 14 13 30 0 13 19 14
Casting aspersions P6 Passed 8 0 0 5 S R S I N N S I S S1 S I S S R R N N 24 14 13 30 0 13 19 14
Neutrality and conflicts of interest P7 Passed 7 1 0 5 S R O I N N S I S S1 S I S S R R N N 24 14 13 30 0 13 19 14
Advocacy P7.1 Failed 3 4 0 5 O R S1 I N N S I O S O I O R R N N 9 0 0 15 0 20 5
Biographies of living people P8 Passed 8 0 0 5 S R S I N N S I S S1 S I S S R R N N 24 14 13 30 0 13 19 14
Encyclopedic coverage of science P9 Passed 8 0 0 5 S R S I N N S I S S1 S I S S R R N N 24 14 13 30 0 13 19 14
Undue weight P10 Passed 8 0 0 5 S R S I N N S I S S1 S I S S R R N N 24 14 13 30 0 13 19 14
Sourcing P11 Passed 8 0 0 5 S R S I N N S I S S1 S I S S R R N N 24 14 13 30 0 13 19 14
Disruptive editing P12 Passed 8 0 0 5 S R S I N N S I S S1 S I S S R R N N 24 14 13 30 0 13 19 14
Blocking and Banning P13 Passed 8 0 0 5 S R S I N N S I S S1 S I S S R R N N 25 14 13 30 0 13 19 14
Administrators P14 Failed* 7 0 0 5 S R I N N S I S S1 S I S S R R N N 25 13 30 0 13 13 14
Administrators working in contentious areas P14.1 Passed 8 0 0 5 S R S I N N S I S S S I S1 S R R N N 12 1 1 17 0 0 0 1
Administrator involvement - general P15 Passed 8 0 0 5 S R S I N N S I S S1 S I S S R R N N 25 14 13 30 0 13 19 14
Involved administrators P15.1 Failed* 6 0 0 5 S R S I N N I S S I S1 S R R N N 4 2 4 3 0 7
Administrator involvement - enforcement matters P16 Passed 7 1 0 5 S R O I N N S I S S1 S I S S R R N N 25 14 13 30 0 13 19 14
Administrator participation in enforcement P17 Passed 8 0 0 5 S R S I N N S I S S1 S I S S R R N N 25 14 13 30 0 13 19 14
Right to vanish P18 Failed* 5 3 0 5 S R O I N N S I O S S I S1 O R R N N 12 1 0 17 0 0 0 1
Right to vanish P18.1 Passed 8 0 0 5 S R S1 I N N S I S S S I S S R R N N 11 0 0 16 0 21 0 0
Detrimental editing P19 Passed 8 0 0 5 S R S I N N S1 I S S S I S S R R N N 11 0 0 16 0 21 0 1
Conduct on arbitration pages P20 Passed 8 0 0 5 S R S I N N S I S S1 S I S S R R N N 10 1 0 15 0 20 5 5
Battlefield editing P21 Passed 7 0 0 5 S R S I N N I S S S I S1 S R R N N 7 0 11 0 17 0 1
Enough is enough P22 Passed 7 0 0 5 S R S I N N I S S S I S1 S R R N N 7 0 11 0 17 0 1
Evidence sub-pages in user space P23 Passed 7 0 0 5 S R S I N N I S S S I S1 S R R N N 11 8 0 0 3 0 2
Locus of dispute F1 Failed* 8 0 0 5 S R S I N N S I S S1 S I S S R R N N 33 4 4 24 0 4 3 4
Locus of dispute F1.1 Passed 8 0 0 5 S R S I N N S I S S1 S I S S R R N N 33 4 4 24 0 4 3 4
Nature and extent of dispute F2 Passed 7 1 0 5 S R S I N N O I S S1 S I S S R R N N 33 4 4 24 0 4 9 4
Climate change probation F3 Passed 8 0 0 5 S R S I N N S I S S1 S I S S R R N N 33 4 4 24 0 4 9 4
Disputes regarding administrator involvement F4 Passed 8 0 0 5 S R S I N N S I S S1 S I S S R R N N 33 4 4 24 0 4 9 4
Sockpuppetry in the Climate Change topic area F5 Passed 8 0 0 5 S R S I N N S I S S1 S I S S R R N N 33 4 4 24 0 4 9 39
Edit warring on Climate Change related articles F6 Failed* 4 2 2 4 S R A I N N A I O S1 S I O S R R N N 33 4 4 24 0 6 9 4
Edit warring on Climate Change related articles F6.1 Passed 7 0 0 5 S R S I N N I S S1 S I S S R R N N 28 1 19 0 1 5 4
Personalization of dispute F7 Passed 8 0 0 5 S R S I N N S1 I S S S I S S R R N N 29 0 0 20 0 21 6 1
William M. Connolley previously sanctioned and desysopped F8.1 Passed 6 0 2 4 S R S1 I N N A I S A S I S S R R N N 32 3 3 23 0 24 9 3
William M. Connolley has been uncivil and antagonistic F8.2 Passed 8 0 0 5 S R S I N N S I S S1 S I S S R R N N 33 4 4 24 0 4 9 4
William M. Connolley has shown Ownership F8.3 Failed 0 8 0 5 O R O I N N O I O O O I O O R R N N 29 0 0 20 0 27 6 1
William M. Connolley BLP violations F8.4 Failed* 5 3 0 5 S R S1 I N N O I O O S I S S R R N N 29 0 0 20 0 2 6 1
William M. Connolley's edits to biographies of living persons F8.5 Passed 7 1 0 5 O R S I N N S I S S1 S I S S R R N N 36 0 0 20 0 1 5 0
Polargeo personal attacks and disruption F9 Failed 1 5 1 4 O R A I N N O I O O I O S1 R R N N 31 1 0 20 0 6 1
Polargeo's battlefield conduct F9.1 Passed 7 0 0 5 S R S I N N I S S S I S1 S R R N N 21 5 10 23 17 0 11
Thegoodlocust long-term disruption F10.1 Passed 8 0 0 5 S R S I N N S1 I S S S I S S R R N N 31 0 0 20 5 27 6 1
Thegoodlocust's battlefield conduct F10.2 Passed 7 0 0 5 S R S I N N I S S S I S S1 R R N N 20 4 10 22 17 8 0
Marknutley disruptive behavior F11 Passed 8 0 0 5 S R S I N N S1 I S S S I S S R R N N 31 0 0 20 5 27 6 1
Lar blocks William M. Connolley F12 Failed 0 5 3 3 O R A I N N O I O O A I O A R R N N 34 4 4 24 0 31 9 4
Lar and Jehochman revert war F12.1 Failed 0 6 2 4 O R A I N N O I O O O I O A R R N N 34 4 4 24 0 31 9 4
RFC/U on Lar F12.2 Passed 8 0 0 5 S R S I N N S1 I S S S I S S R R N N 31 0 0 20 5 27 6 1
Lar's comments, actions, and mindset F12.3 Passed 7 0 1 4 S R S I N N S1 I S A S I S S R R N N 31 0 0 20 32 27 10 1
Stephan Schulz edits and admin actions F13 Failed 0 7 0 5 O R I N N O I O O O I O O R R N N 34 4 24 0 31 9 4
Administrator participation by Stephan Schulz F13.1 Passed 8 0 0 5 S R S I N N S I S S1 S I S S R R N N 32 2 2 22 0 29 8 3
ChrisO's previous arbcom sanctions F14.1 Failed* 4 2 2 4 O R S I N N A I S O A I S1 S R R N N 33 2 2 22 0 29 1 3
ChrisO has made personal attacks F14.2 Failed* 6 2 0 5 O R S I N N S I S O S I S1 S R R N N 33 2 2 22 0 29 1 3
ChrisO's battlefield conduct F14.3 Passed 6 0 0 5 S R I N N I S S S I S1 S R R N N 16 4 17 11 0 5
Minor4th's battlefield conduct F15 Passed 7 0 0 5 S R S I N N I S S S I S S1 R R N N 27 0 16 29 23 2 0
ATren's battlefield conduct F16 Passed 6 0 1 4 S R S I N N I S A S I S S1 R R N N 27 0 15 29 22 15 0
Hipocrite's battlefield conduct F17 Passed 6 0 1 4 S R S I N N I S A S I S S1 R R N N 27 0 15 28 22 1 0
Cla68's battlefield conduct F18 Passed 6 0 1 4 S R S I N N I S S S I A S1 R R N N 26 0 29 33 22 0 0
Scjessey's battlefield conduct F19 Passed 7 0 0 5 S R S I N N I S S S I S1 S R R N N 26 4 14 27 21 0 0
Scjessey's voluntary editing restriction F19.1 Passed 6 0 0 5 S R I N N I S S S I S1 S R R N N 8 10 9 4 0 10
GregJackP's battlefield conduct F20 Passed 7 0 0 5 S R S I N N I S S S I S S1 R R N N 24 2 13 26 20 3 0
A Quest For Knowledge's battlefield conduct F21 Passed 7 0 0 5 S R S I N N I S S S I S1 S R R N N 22 5 10 24 18 0 11
KimDabelsteinPetersen's battlefield conduct F22 Passed 6 0 1 4 S R S I N N I S A S I S1 S R R N N 17 11 4 17 11 0 5
Verbal's battlefield conduct F23 Passed 7 0 0 5 S R S I N N I S S S I S1 S R R N N 15 9 2 16 9 0 3
ZuluPapa5's battlefield conduct F24 Passed 7 0 0 5 S R S I N N I S S S I S1 S R R N N 8 2 9 8 2 0 0
JohnWBarber's battlefield conduct F25 Failed 4 3 0 5 O R S I N N I S O O I S S1 R R N N 6 0 7 11 9 4 0
JohnWBarber's battlefield conduct F25.1 Passed 7 0 0 5 S R S1 I N N I S S S I S S R R N N 1 0 2 3 0 0 0
FellGleaming's battlefield conduct F26 Passed 7 0 0 5 S R S I N N I S S S I S1 S R R N N 3 0 4 4 6 0 1
Discretionary sanctions R1 Failed 3 5 0 5 O R O I N N O I O S1 S I O S R R N N 35 2 2 36 0 2 27 3
Discretionary sanctions R1.1 Failed 4 4 0 5 O R S I N N S1 I O S O I O S R R N N 33 0 0 34 1 1 25 1
Climate change: discretionary sanctions R1.2 Passed 6 1 0 5 S R O I N N I S S S I S1 S R R N N 8 2 9 9 3 0 7
Climate change sanctions noticeboard superseded R2 Passed 8 0 0 5 S R S I N N S I S S1 S I S S R R N N 34 2 2 36 0 2 7 3
Scope of topic bans R3.1 Passed 7 0 0 5 S R S I N N I S S S I S1 S R R N N 21 16 23 0 16 0 10
Appeal of topic bans R3.2 Failed* 7 0 0 5 S R S I N N I S S S I S1 S R R N N 21 3 23 0 16 0 10
Appeal of topic bans R3.2.1 Passed 7 0 0 5 S R S I N N I S S1 S I S S R R N N 21 3 23 0 16 1 9
Administrators who participate in Arbitration and Community Sanction enforcement R4.1 Passed 7 0 0 5 S R S I N N S I S S1 S I S R R N N 34 2 2 36 0 2 2
Use of blogs R4.2 Failed* 7 1 0 5 S R S I N N S I S S1 S I O S R R N N 34 2 2 36 0 2 21 2
Use of blogs and self-published sources R4.2.1 Passed 7 0 0 5 S R S I N N I S S S I S1 S R R N N 13 7 14 13 7 0 1
Project-wide policies remain in effect R4.3 Passed 7 0 0 5 S R S I N N S I S S1 S I S R R N N 34 2 2 36 0 2 2
Biographies of Living Persons R4.4 Passed 7 0 0 5 S R S I N N S I S S1 S I S R R N N 34 2 2 36 0 2 2
Administrators, Checkusers, and the Climate change topic area R4.5 Passed 7 0 0 5 S R S I N N S I S S1 S I S R R N N 34 2 2 36 0 2 2
Deletion of evidence sub-pages R4.6 Passed 7 0 0 5 S R S I N N I S S S I S1 S R R N N 14 8 15 0 9 0 2
William M. Connolley banned R5.1 Failed 0 8 0 5 O R O I N N O I O O O I O O R R N N 36 4 4 38 0 4 22 4
William M. Connolley topic-banned (Climate Change) R5.2 Failed 2 3 1 4 R O I N N S1 I O A I O S R R N N 0 0 34 38 18 0
William M. Connolley topic-banned (BLP) R5.3 Failed 4 2 0 5 R S1 I N N S I O S I O S R R N N 0 0 34 38 18 0
William M. Connolley restricted R5.4 Failed 1 5 0 5 R O I N N O I O S1 I O O R R N N 0 0 34 38 18 1
William M. Connolley asked to disengage R5.5 Failed 0 5 1 4 R O I N N O I O A I O O R R N N 0 0 34 0 18 0
William M. Connolley topic-banned R5.6 Passed 7 0 0 5 S R S I N N I S S S I S1 S R R N N 14 9 15 20 9 0 2
Polargeo admonished R6.1 Failed 1 3 0 5 R I N N O I O I O S1 R R N N 0 35 18 1
Polargeo asked to disengage R6.2 Failed 1 4 1 4 R O I N N S1 I O A I O O R R N N 0 0 34 35 18 1
Polargeo topic-banned R6.3 Passed 7 0 0 5 S R S I N N I S S S I S1 S R R N N 14 9 15 17 9 0 2
Thegoodlocust banned R7 Failed 2 4 1 4 A R S1 I N N O I O O I O S R R N N 33 0 0 34 11 18 1
Thegoodlocust topic banned (climate change) R7.1 Failed 3 2 0 5 R I N N S1 I O S I O S R R N N 0 34 35 18 1
Thegoodlocust indefinitely banned (climate change) R7.2 Failed 3 3 0 5 R S I N N S1 I O S I O O R R N N 0 0 34 35 18 21
Thegoodlocust topic-banned R7.3 Passed 7 0 0 5 S R S I N N I S S S I S1 S R R N N 14 9 15 17 9 0 2
Marknutley banned R8.1 Failed 0 4 1 4 A R I N N O I O I O O R R N N 33 0 11 18 1
Marknutley topic banned (climate change) R8.2 Failed 4 2 0 5 R S I N N S1 I O S I O S R R N N 0 0 34 35 18 1
Marknutley topic banned (climate change) R8.3 Failed 3 3 0 5 R S I N N S1 I O S I O O R R N N 0 0 34 35 18 21
Marknutley withdraws by mutual consent R8.4 Failed 2 3 0 5 R I N N S1 I O S I O O R R N N 0 33 11 18 0
Marknutley topic-banned (BLP) R8.5 Failed 3 3 0 5 R S1 I N N O I O S I O S R R N N 0 0 34 35 18 1
Marknutley topic-banned R8.6 Passed 7 0 0 5 S R S I N N I S S S I S1 S R R N N 14 9 15 17 9 0 2
User:Lar and User:Jehochman admonished R9 Failed 0 8 0 5 O R O I N N O I O O O I O O R R N N 35 2 2 36 0 2 20 3
Lar's May 18 block of William M. Connolley affirmed; 2over0 strongly admonished R9.1 Failed 1 7 0 5 O R O I N N O I O O O I O S1 R R N N 36 4 4 38 0 4 22 4
Lar is an uninvolved admin but advised R9.2 Failed 3 4 1 4 O R S1 I N N O I O A O I S S R R N N 38 1 1 35 0 36 19 2
Lar asked to disengage R9.3 Failed 1 3 1 4 R O I N N S1 I A I O O R R N N 0 0 35 18 1
Stephan Schulz is an involved administrator R10 Failed 2 4 1 4 A R S1 I N N O I O O I O S R R N N 35 2 2 36 0 20 3
Stephan Schulz administrator participation R10.1 Passed 8 0 0 5 S R S I N N S I S S1 S I S S R R N N 35 2 2 36 0 2 20 3
Stephan Schulz asked to disengage R10.2 Failed 1 5 1 4 O R O I N N S1 I O O I A O R R N N 33 0 0 34 0 18 1
ChrisO banned from Climate Change article for six months R11.1 Failed 2 5 0 5 R S1 I N N O I O O O I O S R R N N 2 2 36 0 3 20 3
ChrisO banned from BLPs for one year R11.2 Failed 2 5 0 5 R S1 I N N O I O O O I O S R R N N 2 2 36 0 3 20 3
ChrisO restricted to one account R11.3 Failed 0 5 0 5 R O I N N O I O O I O R R N N 0 0 34 0 1
ChrisO instructed R11.4 Passed 8 0 0 5 S R S I N N S I S S1 S I S S R R N N 33 0 0 34 0 1 1 1
ChrisO asked to disengage R11.5 Failed 1 4 1 4 R O I N N S1 I O A I O O R R N N 0 0 34 35 18 1
ChrisO topic-banned R11.6 Passed 7 0 0 5 S R S I N N I S S S I S1 S R R N N 14 9 15 17 9 0 2
Minor4th topic-banned R12 Passed 7 0 0 5 S R S I N N I S S S I S1 S R R N N 14 9 15 17 9 0 2
ATren topic-banned R13 Passed 6 0 1 4 S R S I N N I S A S I S1 S R R N N 14 9 15 17 9 0 2
Hipocrite topic-banned R14 Passed 6 0 1 4 S R S I N N I S A S I S1 S R R N N 14 9 15 17 9 0 2
Cla68 topic-banned R15 Passed 4 0 2 4 S R S I N N I S A I A S1 R R N N 12 6 13 14 0 0
Scjessey's topic ban (remedies) R16 Failed* 6 0 0 5 S R S I N N I S S S I S1 R R N N 12 6 13 14 7 0
Scjessey's voluntary editing restriction R16.1 Passed 7 0 0 5 S R S I N N I S S S I S1 S R R N N 9 11 10 12 4 0 1
GregJackP topic-banned R17 Passed 7 0 0 5 S R S I N N I S S S I S1 S R R N N 14 9 15 17 9 0 2
A Quest For Knowledge topic-banned R18 Passed 6 0 1 4 S R S I N N I S A S I S1 S R R N N 14 9 15 17 9 0 2
KimDabelsteinPetersen: topic-banned R19 Failed 4 3 0 5 O R S1 I N N I S S S I O O R R N N 8 0 7 8 0 8 8
KimDabelsteinPetersen's voluntary editing restriction R19.1 Passed 7 0 0 5 S R S I N N I S S S I S1 S R R N N 0 0 2 0 0 0 0
Verbal topic-banned R20 Passed 6 0 1 4 S R S I N N I S A S I S1 S R R N N 14 9 15 17 9 0 2
ZuluPapa5 topic-banned R21 Passed 7 0 0 5 S R S I N N I S S S I S1 S R R N N 8 2 9 10 3 0 0
JohnWBarber topic-banned R22 Passed 5 0 1 4 S R S I N N I S A I S S1 R R N N 2 3 3 4 0 0
FellGleaming topic-banned R23 Passed 6 0 0 5 S R S I N N I S S I S1 S R R N N 3 5 4 6 0 1
Enforcement by block E1 Passed 7 0 0 5 S R S I N N S I S S1 S I S R R N N 35 2 2 36 0 29 3
Uninvolved administrators E2 Failed 0 4 3 3 O R A I N N I O A O I O A R R N N 35 2 36 0 29 35 3
Involved administrators E2.1 Passed 6 0 0 5 S R S I N N I S S1 I S S R R N N 5 1 7 0 5 4
Logging E3 Passed 8 0 0 5 S R S I N N S I S S1 S I S S R R N N 35 2 2 36 0 29 35 3
Race and intelligence - Proposals (AC=10, R=2, I=2) Disp S O A M Car Chl Cor Fay Fri Her Kir Kni Mai New Ris Rle Rog She Sir Sts Vas Wiz Car Chl Cor Fay Fri Her Kir Kni Mai New Ris Rle Rog She Sir Sts Vas Wiz
Pillars P1 Passed 10 0 0 6 S S S1 I N N S I S S R S S S S R N N 12 0 0 20 29 32 27 29 32 7
Original research P2 Passed 10 0 0 6 S S S1 I N N S I S S R S S S S R N N 12 0 0 20 29 32 27 29 32 7
Primary sources P3 Failed 3 4 2 5 A A S1 I N N O I O S R O O S R N N 12 0 0 20 29 32 29 32 7
Correct use of sources P3.1 Passed 9 0 0 6 S1 S I N N S I S S R S S S S R N N 0 1 8 17 20 14 17 19 10
Self-published sources P4 Failed 4 6 0 6 S O S1 I N N O I S O R O O O S R N N 12 22 0 20 29 32 27 29 32 7
Mediation P5 Passed 10 0 0 6 S S S1 I N N S I S S R S S S S R N N 12 0 0 20 29 32 27 29 32 7
Advocacy P6 Passed 10 0 0 6 S S S1 I N N S I S S R S S S S R N N 12 0 0 20 29 32 27 29 32 7
Single issue editors P7 Failed 4 6 0 6 S O S1 I N N O I O S R O O O S R N N 12 13 0 20 29 32 27 10 32 7
Single purpose accounts P7.1 Passed 9 0 0 6 S S I N N S I S S R S S1 S S R N N 2 1 10 19 22 17 0 22 12
Decorum P8 Passed 9 0 0 6 S1 S I N N S I S S R S S S S R N N 0 10 8 17 20 19 17 19 10
Lengthy evidence and sub-pages P9 Passed 9 0 0 6 S S I N N S I S S R S S1 S S R N N 2 0 2 2 5 3 0 4 1
Tag-team editing P10 Passed 6 0 3 4 A S I N N A I S A R S S1 S S R N N 2 0 2 1 4 3 0 4 1
Focus of the dispute (1) F1 Failed 4 6 0 6 O O S1 I N N O I O S R S O O S R N N 32 33 0 32 33 32 31 31 32 7
Locus and focus of dispute F1.1 Passed 9 0 0 6 S S I N N S I S S R S S1 S S R N N 2 5 2 5 4 3 0 4 1
Focus of the dispute F2 Failed 2 7 1 5 O O S1 I N N O I O S R O O O A R N N 12 0 0 20 33 32 31 31 32 7
Focus of the dispute F2.1 Failed 3 6 0 6 O O I N N O I O S R S O O S1 R N N 10 11 10 11 10 9 9 9 0
Editor behavior F3 Failed 2 8 0 6 O O S1 I N N O I O O R O O S O R N N 12 8 0 20 33 32 31 31 32 7
Informal mediation F4 Passed 10 0 0 6 S S S1 I N N S I S S R S S S S R N N 12 0 0 20 33 32 31 31 32 7
Mathsci (conduct) F5 Failed* 7 2 0 6 O S I N N S I S O R S S1 S S R N N 7 1 2 7 5 4 0 4 2
Mathsci (conduct) F5.1 Passed 8 0 0 6 S1 S I N N S I S S R S S S R N N 0 0 0 1 0 0 1 0
David.Kane (conduct) F6 Passed 9 0 0 6 S S I N N S I S S R S S1 S S R N N 0 1 3 6 6 5 0 5 2
Captain Occam (conduct) F7 Passed 9 0 0 6 S S I N N S I S S R S S1 S S R N N 2 5 2 6 5 4 0 4 1
Mikemikev (conduct) F8 Passed 9 0 0 6 S S I N N S I S S R S S1 S S R N N 4 1 4 11 10 9 0 9 0
Source probation R1 Failed 1 9 0 6 O O S1 I N N O I O O R O O O O R N N 12 2 0 20 33 32 31 31 32 7
Editors reminded R2 Failed 1 9 0 6 O O S1 I N N O I O O R O O O O R N N 12 13 0 20 33 32 31 31 32 29
Topic restrictions (1) R3 Failed 1 9 0 6 O O S1 I N N O I O O R O O O O R N N 12 0 0 20 33 32 31 31 32 7
Topic restrictions (2) R3.1 Failed 1 7 1 5 O A I N N O I O O R O O O S1 R N N 5 2 14 27 26 25 24 25 0
Topic bans on race-related articles R4 Failed 2 6 0 6 S1 I N N O I O O R O O O S R N N 0 8 21 20 19 18 19 16
Discretionary sanctions R5 Failed* 6 2 1 5 O A I N N S1 I S S R S S O S R N N 12 3 0 13 12 11 8 11 9
Editors reminded and discretionary sanctions R5.1 Passed 9 0 0 6 S S I N N S I S S R S S1 S S R N N 2 0 2 6 5 4 0 4 1
Mathsci topic-banned by mutual consent R6 Passed 9 0 0 6 S S I N N S I S S R S S1 S S R N N 4 0 1 4 4 2 0 4 0
Mathsci topic-banned and cautioned R6.1 Failed 0 3 0 6 O I N N O I R O R N N 0 0 0
David.Kane topic-banned R7 Passed 9 0 0 6 S S I N N S I S S R S S1 S S R N N 1 0 1 4 3 2 0 3 0
Captain Occam topic-banned R8 Passed 9 0 0 6 S S I N N S I S S R S S1 S S R N N 1 4 1 4 3 2 0 3 0
Mikemikev site-banned and thereafter topic-banned R9 Passed 9 0 0 6 S S I N N S I S S R S S1 S S R N N 1 0 1 4 3 2 0 3 0
Evidence sub-pages (remedy) R10 Passed 9 0 0 6 S S I N N S I S S R S S1 S S R N N 2 0 1 6 5 4 0 4 1
Enforcement E1 Failed 4 4 0 6 O S1 I N N O I O S R S O S R N N 33 0 32 33 32 31 32 29
Enforcement of topic-bans by block E2 Passed 9 0 0 6 S S I N N S I S S R S S1 S S R N N 1 4 1 4 3 2 0 3 0
Review of topic-bans E3 Passed 9 0 0 6 S S I N N S I S S R S S1 S S R N N 1 4 1 4 3 2 0 3 0
Transcendental Meditation movement - Proposals (AC=11, R=0, I=3) Disp S O A M Car Chl Cor Fay Fri Her Kir Kni Mai New Ris Rle Rog She Sir Sts Vas Wiz Car Chl Cor Fay Fri Her Kir Kni Mai New Ris Rle Rog She Sir Sts Vas Wiz
Purpose of Wikipedia P1 Passed 10 0 0 6 S I I N N S S S S S S S1 S S I N N 4 4 8 17 1 15 1 0 17 1
Neutral point of view and verifiability P2 Passed 10 0 0 6 S I I N N S S S S S S S1 S S I N N 4 4 8 17 1 15 1 0 17 1
Neutrality and conflicts of interest P3 Passed 10 0 0 6 S I I N N S S S S S S S1 S S I N N 4 4 8 17 1 15 1 0 17 1
Neutrality, verifiability and appropriate weight P4 Passed 10 0 0 6 S I I N N S S S S S S S1 S S I N N 4 4 8 17 1 15 1 0 17 1
Neutrality and sources P5 Passed 10 0 0 6 S I I N N S S S S S S S1 S S I N N 4 4 8 17 1 15 1 0 17 1
Use of primary and secondary sources P6 Failed 4 0 2 5 A I I N N S S S S1 A I N N 5 3 4 8 0 6
Accuracy of sourcing P7 Passed 8 0 0 6 S I I N N S S S S S1 S S I N N 6 6 3 4 8 0 6 3
Academic inquiry, article claims and appropriate weight P8 Failed 3 3 3 5 O I I N N A O O A S S1 S A I N N 4 4 8 17 1 1 0 17 1
Decorum and assumptions of good faith P9 Passed 10 0 0 6 S I I N N S S S S S S S1 S S I N N 4 4 8 17 1 15 1 0 17 1
Peremptory reversion or removal of sourced material P10 Passed 7 0 0 6 S I I N N S S S S1 S S I N N 6 6 3 4 0 6 3
Consensus building P11 Passed 10 0 0 6 S I I N N S S S S S S S1 S S I N N 4 4 8 17 1 15 1 0 17 1
Feuds and quarrels P12 Passed 10 0 0 6 S I I N N S S S S S S S1 S S I N N 4 4 8 17 1 15 1 0 17 1
Single purpose accounts P13 Passed 10 0 0 6 S I I N N S S S S S S S1 S S I N N 4 4 8 17 1 15 1 0 17 1
Avoiding apparent impropriety P14 Passed 10 0 0 6 S I I N N S S S S S S S1 S S I N N 4 4 8 17 1 15 1 0 17 1
Recidivism P15 Passed 10 0 0 6 S I I N N S S S S S S S1 S S I N N 4 4 8 17 1 15 1 0 17 1
Off-wiki communication P16 Passed 8 0 0 6 S I I N N S S S S S1 S S I N N 6 6 3 4 6 0 6 3
Off-wiki conduct P17 Passed 8 0 0 6 S I I N N S S S S S1 S S I N N 6 6 3 4 6 0 6 3
Locus of dispute F1 Passed 10 0 0 6 S I I N N S S S S S S S1 S S I N N 8 4 8 18 1 15 1 0 17 1
Background F2 Failed 5 5 0 6 O I I N N O O O S S S S1 O S I N N 8 4 8 18 1 15 1 0 17 1
Background F2.1 Passed 10 0 0 6 S I I N N S S S S1 S S S S S I N N 6 2 6 17 0 13 0 0 16 0
Fladrif F3 Passed 10 0 0 6 S I I N N S S S S S S S1 S S I N N 8 4 8 18 1 15 1 0 17 1
Sockpuppetry, meatpuppetry, and collusion F4 Passed 9 0 0 6 S I I N N S S S S S S S1 S I N N 8 4 8 18 1 15 1 0 17
Tuckerj1976 F5 Passed 9 0 1 6 S I I N N S S S A S S S1 S S I N N 8 4 8 18 1 15 1 0 17 1
All parties instructed R1 Passed 8 0 1 6 S I I N N S S S S S S1 S A I N N 17 22 18 1 15 1 0 17 1
Editors reminded R2 Passed 8 0 1 6 S I I N N S S S S S S1 S A I N N 17 22 18 1 15 1 0 17 1
Discretionary sanctions R3 Passed 9 0 0 6 S I I N N S S S S S S1 S S I N N 17 22 18 1 15 1 0 17 1
Guidance for uninvolved administrators R4 Passed 7 0 0 6 S I I N N S S S S S1 S I N N 2 7 3 0 2 0 2
Periodic review by ArbCom R5 Passed 5 0 4 4 A I I N N A A A S S S1 S S I N N 17 22 18 1 15 1 0 17 1
Fladrif strongly admonished and restricted R6 Passed 9 0 0 6 S I I N N S S S S S S1 S S I N N 17 22 18 1 15 1 0 17 1
Enforcement by block E1 Passed 8 0 1 6 S I I N N S S A S S S1 S S I N N 17 22 18 1 15 1 0 17 1
Russavia-Biophys - Proposals (AC=12, R=0, I=2) Disp S O A M Car Chl Cor Fay Fri Her Kir Kni Mai New Ris Rle Rog She Sir Sts Vas Wiz Car Chl Cor Fay Fri Her Kir Kni Mai New Ris Rle Rog She Sir Sts Vas Wiz
Purpose of Wikipedia P1 Passed 9 0 0 7 S S S I N N S I S S S1 S S N N 1 3 4 4 6 0 0 2 2
Editorial process P2 Passed 9 0 0 7 S S S I N N S I S S S1 S S N N 1 3 4 4 6 0 0 2 2
Neutral point of view P3 Passed 9 0 0 7 S S S I N N S I S S S1 S S N N 1 3 4 4 6 0 0 2 2
National and territorial disputes or similar conflicts P4 Passed 9 0 0 7 S S S I N N S I S S S1 S S N N 1 3 4 4 6 0 0 2 2
Decorum P5 Passed 9 0 0 7 S S S I N N S I S S S1 S S N N 1 3 4 4 6 0 0 2 2
Recidivism P6 Passed 9 0 0 7 S S S I N N S I S S S1 S S N N 1 3 4 4 6 0 0 2 2
Locus of dispute F1 Passed 8 0 0 7 S S I N N S I S S S1 S S N N 1 4 4 6 0 0 2 2
User conduct in this topic area F2 Passed 8 0 0 7 S S I N N S I S S S1 S S N N 1 4 4 6 0 0 2 2
Battlefield mentality F3 Passed 7 0 1 6 S S I N N S I A S S1 S S N N 1 4 4 6 0 0 2 2
Personal information and communications F4 Passed 8 0 0 7 S S I N N S I S S S1 S S N N 1 4 4 6 0 0 2 2
Battlefield mentality F5 Passed 7 0 1 6 S S I N N S I A S S1 S S N N 1 4 4 6 0 0 2 2
Edit warring F6 Passed 8 0 0 7 S S I N N S I S S S1 S S N N 1 4 4 6 0 0 2 2
Personal information F7 Passed 8 0 0 7 S S I N N S I S S S1 S S N N 1 4 4 6 0 0 2 2
Edit warring F8 Passed 8 0 0 7 S S I N N S I S S S1 S S N N 1 4 4 6 0 0 2 2
Combative editing F9 Passed 8 0 0 7 S S I N N S I S S S1 S S N N 1 4 4 6 0 0 2 2
Battlefield mentality F10 Passed 8 0 0 7 S S I N N S I S S S1 S S N N 1 4 4 6 0 0 2 2
Edit warring F11 Passed 8 0 0 7 S S I N N S I S S S1 S S N N 1 4 4 6 0 0 2 2
Battlefield mentality F12 Passed 7 0 1 6 S S I N N S I A S S1 S S N N 1 4 4 6 0 0 2 2
Edit warring F13 Passed 8 0 0 7 S S I N N S I S S S1 S S N N 1 4 4 6 0 0 2 2
Russavia restricted R1 Passed 8 0 0 7 S S I N N S I S S S1 S S N N 1 4 4 6 0 0 2 2
Russavia admonished R2 Passed 7 0 1 6 S S I N N S I S A S1 S S N N 1 4 4 6 0 0 2 2
Biophys topic banned R3 Passed 8 0 0 7 S S I N N S I S S S1 S S N N 1 4 4 6 0 0 2 2
Biophys restricted R4 Passed 8 0 0 7 S S I N N S I S S S1 S S N N 1 4 4 6 0 0 2 2
Vlad fedorov topic banned R5 Passed 8 0 0 7 S S I N N S I S S S1 S S N N 1 4 4 6 0 0 2 2
Vlad fedorov admonished R6 Passed 8 0 0 7 S S I N N S I S S S1 S S N N 1 4 4 6 0 0 2 2
Ellol topic banned R7 Passed 7 0 1 6 S S I N N S I A S S1 S S N N 1 4 4 6 0 0 2 2
YMB29 topic banned R8 Passed 7 0 1 6 S S I N N S I A S S1 S S N N 1 4 4 6 0 0 2 2
Editors reminded R9 Passed 8 0 0 7 S S I N N S I S S S1 S S N N 1 4 4 6 0 0 2 2
Enforcement by block E1 Passed 8 0 0 7 S S I N N S I S S S1 S S N N 1 4 4 6 0 0 2 2
Gibraltar - Proposals (AC=8, R=2, I=5) Disp S O A M Car Chl Cor Fay Fri Her Kir Kni Mai New Ris Rle Rog She Sir Sts Vas Wiz Car Chl Cor Fay Fri Her Kir Kni Mai New Ris Rle Rog She Sir Sts Vas Wiz
Purpose of Wikipedia P1 Passed 8 0 0 5 S I S I N I R S I S1 S S R S S I N N 10 15 8 0 0 3 5 0
Conduct and decorum P2 Passed 8 0 0 5 S I S I N I R S I S1 S S R S S I N N 10 15 8 0 0 3 5 0
Consensus P3 Passed 8 0 0 5 S I S I N I R S I S1 S S R S S I N N 10 15 8 0 0 3 5 0
Neutral point of view P4 Passed 8 0 0 5 S I S I N I R S I S1 S S R S S I N N 10 15 8 0 0 3 5 0
Fact versus opinion P5 Passed 7 0 1 4 A I S I N I R S I S1 S S R S S I N N 10 15 8 0 0 3 5 0
National and territorial disputes and similar conflicts P6 Passed 8 0 0 5 S I S I N I R S I S1 S S R S S I N N 10 15 8 0 0 3 5 0
Anonymity and conflicts of interest P7 Passed 8 0 0 5 S I S I N I R S I S1 S S R S S I N N 10 15 8 0 0 3 5 0
Locus of dispute F1 Passed 8 0 0 5 S I S I N I R S I S1 S S R S S I N N 10 15 8 0 1 3 5 0
User conduct on Gibraltar F2 Passed 8 0 0 5 S I S I N I R S I S1 S S R S S I N N 10 15 8 0 1 3 5 0
Gibnews F3 Passed 8 0 0 5 S I S I N I R S I S1 S S R S S I N N 10 15 8 0 7 3 5 0
Justin A Kuntz F4 Passed 8 0 0 5 S I S I N I R S I S1 S S R S S I N N 10 15 8 0 7 3 5 0
The Red Hat of Pat Ferrick F5 Failed 4 4 0 5 S I O I N I R O I O S S1 R S O I N N 10 14 18 20 7 3 5 0
Ecemaml F6 Passed 5 1 2 4 S I S I N I R O I A S S1 R S A I N N 10 15 18 0 7 3 5 1
Discretionary sanctions R1 Passed 8 0 0 5 S I S I N I R S I S1 S S R S S I N N 10 15 8 0 7 3 5 0
Appeal of discretionary sanctions R2 Passed 8 0 0 5 S I S I N I R S I S1 S S R S S I N N 10 15 8 0 7 3 5 0
Gibnews topic-banned R3 Passed 8 0 0 5 S I S I N I R S I S1 S S R S S I N N 10 15 8 0 7 3 5 0
Gibnews topic-banned R3.1 Failed* 8 0 0 5 S I S I N I R S I S1 S S R S S I N N 10 15 8 0 7 3 5 0
Gibnews warned R4 Passed 8 0 0 5 S I S I N I R S I S1 S S R S S I N N 10 15 8 0 7 3 5 0
Justin A Kuntz topic-banned R5 Passed 8 0 0 5 S I S I N I R S I S1 S S R S S I N N 10 15 8 0 7 3 5 1
The Red Hat of Pat Ferrick admonished R6 Failed 4 4 0 5 S I O I N I R O I O S S1 R S O I N N 10 14 18 20 7 3 5 0
Ecemaml R7 Failed 3 4 1 4 S I O I N I R O I O A S1 R S O I N N 10 15 18 0 7 3 5 0
Ecemaml R7.1 Passed 7 1 0 5 S I S I N I R O I S1 S S R S S I N N 0 3 6 0 6 0 1 1
Editors reminded R8 Passed 8 0 0 5 S I S I N I R S I S1 S S R S S I N N 10 15 8 0 7 3 5 0
Conflicts of interest R9 Passed 8 0 0 5 S I S I N I R S I S1 S S R S S I N N 10 15 8 0 7 3 5 0
Enforcement of discretionary sanctions E1 Passed 8 0 0 5 S I S I N I R S I S1 S S R S S I N N 10 15 8 0 7 3 6 1
Enforcement of decision sanctions E2 Passed 8 0 0 5 S I S I N I R S I S1 S S R S S I N N 10 15 8 0 7 3 6 1
Alastair Haines 2 - Proposals (AC=10, R=0, I=5) Disp S O A M Car Chl Cor Fay Fri Her Kir Kni Mai New Ris Rle Rog She Sir Sts Vas Wiz Car Chl Cor Fay Fri Her Kir Kni Mai New Ris Rle Rog She Sir Sts Vas Wiz
Purpose of Wikipedia P1 Passed 8 0 0 6 S I S I N I S S I S1 S S S I N N 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0
The Wikipedia model P2 Passed 8 0 0 6 S I S I N I S S I S1 S S S I N N 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0
Editorial process P3 Passed 8 0 0 6 S I S I N I S S I S1 S S S I N N 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0
Legal threats P4 Passed 8 0 0 6 S I S I N I S S I S1 S S S I N N 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0
Perceived legal threats P5 Passed 8 0 0 6 S I S I N I S S I S1 S S S I N N 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0
Legal threats against the Wikimedia Foundation P6 Passed 8 0 0 6 S I S I N I S S I S1 S S S I N N 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0
Discussions and usernames P7 Passed 8 0 0 6 S I S I N I S S I S1 S S S I N N 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0
Repetition of improper conduct P8 Passed 8 0 0 6 S I S I N I S S I S1 S S S I N N 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0
Prior arbitration case F1 Passed 8 0 0 6 S I S I N I S S I S1 S S S I N N 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0
Continuing legal threats F2 Passed 8 0 0 6 S I S I N I S S I S1 S S S I N N 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0
Legal threats during this arbitration case F3 Passed 8 0 0 6 S I S I N I S S I S1 S S S I N N 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0
Alastair Haines and Wikipedia F4 Passed 8 0 0 6 S I S I N I S S I S1 S S S I N N 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0
Other issues F5 Passed 8 0 0 6 S I S I N I S S I S1 S S S I N N 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0
Alastair Haines banned R1 Passed 8 0 0 6 S I S I N I S S I S1 S S S I N N 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0
Alastair Haines return to editing R2 Passed 8 0 0 6 S I S I N I S S I S1 S S S I N N 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0
Courtesy blanking and disengagement R3 Passed 8 1 0 6 S I S I N I S S I S1 S O S S I N N 0 0 1 1 0 0 1 0 0
Asgardian - Proposals (AC=14, R=0, I=2) Disp S O A M Car Chl Cor Fay Fri Her Kir Kni Mai New Ris Rle Rog She Sir Sts Vas Wiz Car Chl Cor Fay Fri Her Kir Kni Mai New Ris Rle Rog She Sir Sts Vas Wiz
Edit warring is prohibited P1 Passed 10 0 0 8 S N S S S1 S S I S S S S N I 2 4 0 0 5 0 2 0 3 0
Editorial process P2 Passed 10 0 0 8 S N S S S1 S S I S S S S N I 2 4 0 0 5 0 2 0 3 0
Article ownership P3 Passed 9 0 1 7 A N S S S1 S S I S S S S N I 2 4 0 0 5 0 2 0 3 0
Edit summaries P4 Passed 10 0 0 8 S N S S S1 S S I S S S S N I 2 4 0 0 5 0 2 0 3 0
Editor decorum P5 Passed 10 0 0 8 S N S S S1 S S I S S S S N I 2 4 0 0 5 0 2 0 3 0
Recidivism P6 Passed 10 0 0 8 S N S S S1 S S I S S S S N I 2 4 0 0 5 0 2 0 3 0
Past case F1 Passed 10 0 0 8 S N S S S1 S S I S S S S N I 2 4 0 0 5 0 2 0 3 0
Edit-warring F2 Passed 10 0 0 8 S N S S S1 S S I S S S S N I 3 4 0 0 5 0 2 0 3 0
Edit summaries F3 Passed 10 0 0 8 S N S S S1 S S I S S S S N I 2 4 0 0 5 0 2 0 3 0
Incivility F4 Passed 10 0 0 8 S N S S S1 S S I S S S S N I 3 4 0 0 5 0 2 0 3 0
Asgardian banned R1 Passed 9 1 0 8 O N S S S1 S S I S S S S N I 3 4 0 0 5 0 2 0 3 0
ChildofMidnight - Proposals (AC=11, R=1, I=4) Disp S O A M Car Chl Cor Fay Fri Her Kir Kni Mai New Ris Rle Rog She Sir Sts Vas Wiz Car Chl Cor Fay Fri Her Kir Kni Mai New Ris Rle Rog She Sir Sts Vas Wiz
Casting aspersions P1 Passed 10 0 0 6 I R S1 I N I S S S S S S S S S N I 0 2 3 1 1 3 2 4 1 3
Vested contributors P2 Passed 10 0 0 6 I R S1 I N I S S S S S S S S S N I 0 2 3 1 1 3 2 4 1 3
Fair criticism P3 Passed 10 0 0 6 I R S1 I N I S S S S S S S S S N I 0 2 3 1 1 3 2 4 1 3
Purpose of Wikipedia P4 Passed 10 0 0 6 I R S1 I N I S S S S S S S S S N I 0 2 3 1 1 3 2 4 1 3
User conduct P5 Passed 10 0 0 6 I R S1 I N I S S S S S S S S S N I 0 2 3 1 1 3 2 4 1 3
Wikipedia is not a battleground P6 Passed 10 0 0 6 I R S1 I N I S S S S S S S S S N I 0 2 3 1 1 3 2 4 1 3
ChildofMidnight F1 Failed 3 7 0 6 I R O I N I O S O S1 S O O O O N I 0 1 3 3 1 2 2 3 1 3
Past sanctions F2 Passed 10 0 0 6 I R S1 I N I S S S S S S S S S N I 0 1 3 3 1 2 2 3 1 3
Request for Comment F3 Passed 10 0 0 6 I R S1 I N I S S S S S S S S S N I 0 1 3 3 1 2 2 3 1 3
ChildofMidnight's reaction to the Request for Comment F4 Passed 10 0 0 6 I R S1 I N I S S S S S S S S S N I 0 1 3 3 1 2 2 3 1 3
ChildofMidnight's history F5 Passed 10 0 0 6 I R S1 I N I S S S S S S S S S N I 0 1 3 3 1 2 2 3 1 3
ChildofMidnight's dealings with criticism F6 Passed 10 0 0 6 I R S1 I N I S S S S S S S S S N I 0 1 3 3 1 2 2 3 1 3
ChildofMidnight banned R1 Passed 10 0 0 6 I R S1 I N I S S S S S S S S S N I 0 1 2 2 1 2 1 3 3 2
ChildofMidnight restricted R2 Passed 10 0 0 6 I R S1 I N I S S S S S S S S S N I 0 1 2 2 1 2 1 3 3 2
Enforcement by block E1 Passed 10 0 0 6 I R S1 I N I S S S S S S S S S N I 0 1 2 2 1 2 1 3 3 2
Chabad movement - Proposals (AC=12, R=0, I=5) Disp S O A M Car Chl Cor Fay Fri Her Kir Kni Mai New Ris Rle Rog She Sir Sts Vas Wiz Car Chl Cor Fay Fri Her Kir Kni Mai New Ris Rle Rog She Sir Sts Vas Wiz
Purpose of Wikipedia P1 Passed 10 0 0 7 I S I I S I S S S S1 S S S S N I 1 0 1 1 2 0 0 0 1 0
Neutral point of view and undue weight P2 Passed 10 0 0 7 I S I I S I S S S S1 S S S S N I 1 0 1 1 2 0 0 0 1 0
Decorum P3 Passed 10 0 0 7 I S I I S I S S S S1 S S S S N I 1 0 1 1 2 0 0 0 1 0
Consensus P4 Passed 10 0 0 7 I S I I S I S S S S1 S S S S N I 1 0 1 1 2 0 0 0 1 0
Role of the Arbitration Committee P5 Passed 10 0 0 7 I S I I S I S S S S1 S S S S N I 1 0 1 1 2 0 0 0 1 0
Locus of dispute F1 Passed 9 0 1 6 I S I I S I S S S S1 S S S A N I 1 0 1 1 2 0 0 0 1 0
Content disputes F2 Passed 10 0 0 7 I S I I S I S S S S1 S S S S N I 1 0 1 1 2 0 0 0 1 0
User conduct F3 Passed 10 0 0 7 I S I I S I S S S S1 S S S S N I 1 0 1 1 2 0 0 0 1 0
Editors reminded R1 Passed 10 0 0 7 I S I I S I S S S S1 S S S S N I 1 0 1 1 2 0 0 0 1 0
Editors encouraged R2 Passed 10 0 0 7 I S I I S I S S S S1 S S S S N I 1 0 1 1 2 0 0 0 1 0
Future proceedings R3 Passed 10 0 0 7 I S I I S I S S S S1 S S S S N I 1 0 1 1 2 0 0 0 1 0
MZMcBride 2 - Proposals (AC=12, R=1, I=4) Disp S O A M Car Chl Cor Fay Fri Her Kir Kni Mai New Ris Rle Rog She Sir Sts Vas Wiz Car Chl Cor Fay Fri Her Kir Kni Mai New Ris Rle Rog She Sir Sts Vas Wiz
Administrator conduct P1 Passed 12 0 0 7 I R S I S I S S S S S S S1 S S S N I 1 0 3 3 4 5 3 4 0 1 0 1
Return of access levels P2 Passed 12 0 0 7 I R S I S I S S S S S S S1 S S S N I 1 0 3 3 4 5 3 4 0 1 0 1
Recidivism P3 Passed 11 0 1 6 I R S I S I S S S S S S S1 S S A N I 1 0 3 3 4 5 3 4 0 1 0 1
Disruption to prove a point P4 Passed 12 0 0 7 I R S I S I S S S S S S S1 S S S N I 1 5 3 3 4 5 3 4 0 1 0 1
Vandalism P5 Passed 11 0 1 6 I R S I S I S S S S A S S1 S S S N I 1 1 3 3 4 5 3 4 0 1 0 1
Serious accusations P6 Passed 6 0 6 4 I R S I S I A A A A A S S1 S A S N I 1 0 3 3 4 5 3 4 0 1 0 1
Derogatory remarks P7 Failed 4 4 4 5 I R S I S I O O A A A S S1 O A O N I 1 0 6 5 4 5 3 4 0 1 0 1
MZMcBride's editing history F1 Passed 12 0 0 7 I R S I S I S S S S S S S1 S S S N I 1 0 3 3 4 5 3 4 0 1 0 1
MZMcBride's role in an "experiment" F2 Passed 12 0 0 7 I R S I S I S S S S S S S1 S S S N I 1 0 3 3 4 5 3 4 0 1 0 1
MZMcBride's sockpuppetry posting F3 Passed 9 2 1 6 I R S I O I S S S S A S S1 S S O N I 1 0 3 3 4 5 3 4 0 1 0 1
MZMcBride and Toolserver F4 Passed 11 0 1 6 I R S I S I S S S S A S S1 S S S N I 1 0 3 3 4 5 3 4 0 1 0 1
MZMcBride's judgment F5 Passed 11 0 1 6 I R S I S I S S S S S S S1 S S A N I 1 0 3 3 4 5 3 4 0 1 0 1
Durova's commentaries F6A Failed 5 6 1 6 I R S I S1 I O O O O A S O S O S N I 1 0 2 4 5 5 3 4 5 2 4 0
Durova's commentaries F6B Failed 5 5 2 6 I R S I S I O O O O A S S1 S O A N I 1 0 3 5 5 5 3 4 0 1 5 1
MZMcBride's administrator status R1 Failed* 11 1 0 7 I R S I O I S S S S S S S1 S S S N I 1 0 3 4 4 5 3 4 0 1 0 1
MZMcBride's administrator status R1.1 Failed 2 10 0 7 I R O I O I O O O S O O O O S1 O N I 1 0 3 4 4 5 3 4 1 1 0 1
MZMcBride's administrator status R1.2 Passed 11 0 0 7 I R S I S1 I S S S S S S S S S N I 1 0 2 3 4 5 3 4 1 1 0
MZMcBride's administrator status R1.3 Failed* 7 4 0 7 I R O I S I S O S S O S O S S1 N I 0 0 2 3 4 4 2 3 0 0 0
MZMcBride admonished R2 Passed 11 0 1 6 I R S I S I S S S S S S S1 S S A N I 1 0 3 4 4 5 3 4 0 1 0 1
MZMcBride admonished R2.1 Passed 6 2 2 6 I R I S I S A S S O S A O S1 N I 0 2 3 4 4 2 3 0 4 0
Durova cautioned R3 Failed 5 6 1 6 I R S I S1 I O O O O A S O S O S N I 1 0 2 4 5 5 3 4 5 1 4 0
Toolserver access R4 Failed 4 6 1 6 I R S1 I O I O O O A O S O S S N I 0 3 2 3 3 4 2 3 3 4 4

Proposals: 347; passed: 266 (77%); failed: 81 (23%).

For cases involving 2010 and departing 2009 arbs

[edit]
Proposals for cases involving 2010 and departing 2009 arbs
Tothwolf - Proposals (AC=9, R=0, I=10) Disp S O A M Car Chl Cor Fay Fri Her Kir Kni Mai New Ris Rle Rog She Sir Ste Sts Vas Wiz Car Chl Cor Fay Fri Her Kir Kni Mai New Ris Rle Rog She Sir Ste Sts Vas Wiz
Harassment P1 Passed 8 0 0 5 S I I I S I I S S I I S I S S1 I S I 1 1 5 1 13 1 0 1
Hounding P2 Passed 8 0 0 5 S I I I S I I S S I I S I S S1 I S I 1 1 5 1 13 1 0 1
Dealing with harassment P3 Passed 8 0 0 5 S I I I S I I S S I I S I S S1 I S I 1 1 5 1 13 1 0 1
Conflicts of interest P4 Passed 5 0 3 4 S I I I A I I S A I I A I S S1 I S I 1 1 5 1 13 1 0 1
Handling conflicts of interest P5 Passed 6 0 2 4 S I I I A I I S A I I S I S S1 I S I 1 1 5 1 13 1 0 1
Fait accompli P6 Passed 8 0 0 5 S I I I S I I S S I I S I S S1 I S I 1 1 5 1 13 1 0 1
Deletion best practices P7 Passed 8 0 0 5 S I I I S I I S S I I S I S S1 I S I 1 1 5 1 13 1 0 1
Decorum P8 Passed 8 0 0 5 S I I I S I I S S I I S I S S1 I S I 1 1 5 1 13 1 0 1
Casting aspersions P9 Passed 8 0 0 5 S I I I S I I S S I I S I S S1 I S I 1 1 5 1 13 1 0 1
Deletion nominations F1 Passed 8 0 0 5 S I I I S I I S S I I S I S S1 I S I 14 1 15 20 13 1 0 1
Deletion nominations and harassment F2 Passed 8 0 0 5 S I I I S I I S S I I S I S S1 I S I 14 1 15 20 13 1 0 1
Deletion nominations F3 Passed 8 0 0 5 S I I I S I I S S I I S I S S1 I S I 14 1 15 20 13 1 0 1
Deletion nominations and harassment F4 Passed 8 0 0 5 S I I I S I I S S I I S I S S1 I S I 14 1 15 20 13 1 0 1
Decorum F5 Failed 1 6 1 5 O I I I O I I O O I I O I O S1 I A I 14 1 15 20 13 1 0 1
Decorum F5.1 Passed 6 1 1 5 S I I I S1 I I S A I I S I S S I O I 13 0 14 19 12 5 2 4
Allegations against other editors F6 Passed 8 0 0 5 S I I I S I I S S I I S I S S1 I S I 14 1 15 20 13 1 0 1
Decorum F7 Passed 8 0 0 5 S I I I S I I S S I I S I S S1 I S I 14 1 15 20 13 1 0 1
Tothwolf restricted R1 Passed 6 0 2 4 S I I I S I I S S I I S I A S1 I A I 14 1 15 20 15 1 0 1
Tothwolf restricted R1.1 Failed* 5 1 2 4 O I I I S1 I I S S I I S I A A I S I 14 0 14 19 15 14 2 5
JBsupreme warned R2 Passed 5 0 3 4 S I I I S I I S A I I S I A S1 I A I 14 3 15 20 15 1 0 1
Miami33139 and JBsupreme reminded R3 Passed 6 1 1 5 S I I I S I I S A I I S I S S1 I O I 14 1 15 20 15 1 0 1
Editors reminded R4 Passed 6 0 2 4 S I I I A I I S A I I S I S S1 I S I 14 1 15 20 15 1 0 1
Enforcement by block E1 Passed 6 1 1 5 S I I I S I I S S I I S I A S1 I O I 14 1 15 20 15 1 0 1

Proposals: 23; passed: 21 (91%); failed: 2 (9%).

  • Failed*: Although receiving enough supports to pass, the proposal failed due either to preferential or conditional voting.

Arb activity

[edit]

Legend

[edit]

In the two tables below, the column headings have the following meanings:

  • EP (eligible proposals): The total number of proposals in cases for which this arb was eligible to act (count of non-"N"s).
  • I (inactive): The total number of proposals in cases for which this arb was listed on the case's "Proposed decision" talk page as inactive/away (count of "I"s); as a percentage of EP.
  • R (recused): The total number of proposals in cases for which this arb was listed on the case's "Proposed decision" talk page as recused (count of "R"s); as a percentage of (EP − I).
  • V (voted): The total number of proposals this arb voted to support or oppose (count of "S"s or "O"s); as a percentage of (EP - (I + R)).
  • A (abstained): The total number of proposals for which this arb abstained (count of "A"s), as a percentage of (EP - (I + R)).
  • DNA (did not act): The total number of proposals in cases for which this arb was listed on the case's "Proposed decision" talk page as active, but did not act (count of empty cells); as a percentage of (EP - (I + R)).
  • S (supported): The total number of proposals this arb supported (count of "S"s); as a percentage of V.
  • O (opposed): The total number of proposals this arb opposed (count of "O"s); as a percentage of V.
  • FS (first support): The number of times this arb was first to support the proposal, which is generally indicative of having drafted the proposal (count of "S1"s); as a percentage of total number of proposals drafted.
  • ATV (average (mean) time to vote), MTV (median time to vote): For all the proposals this arb acted on (i.e. supported, opposed, or abstained), the average (mean) and the median of the length of time (in days) between the first action on the proposal and this arb's action on the proposal.

Arb activity (2010)

[edit]
Arb activity (2010) — case proposals
Arb EP I % R % V % A % DNA % S % O % FS % ATV MTV
Carcharoth 370 48 13% 0 0% 296 92% 9 3% 17 5% 258 87% 38 13% 4 1% 12.0 10.0
Cool Hand Luke 370 109 29% 171 66% 50 56% 3 3% 37 41% 41 82% 9 18% 0 0% 3.3 1.0
Coren 370 11 3% 0 0% 256 71% 6 2% 97 27% 233 91% 23 9% 44 12% 4.0 2.0
FayssalF 370 345 93% 0 0% 12 48% 2 8% 11 44% 11 92% 1 8% 0 0% 1.2 1.0
Fritzpoll 56 23 41% 0 0% 33 100% 0 0% 0 0% 29 88% 4 12% 3 1% 0.3 0.0
Hersfold 124 90 73% 0 0% 31 91% 3 9% 0 0% 30 97% 1 3% 2 1% 2.0 1.0
Kirill Lokshin 370 23 6% 26 7% 225 70% 6 2% 90 28% 181 80% 44 20% 31 8% 3.9 2.0
KnightLago 370 196 53% 0 0% 165 95% 4 2% 5 3% 150 91% 15 9% 11 3% 4.7 4.0
Mailer diablo 370 71 19% 0 0% 275 92% 3 1% 21 7% 220 80% 55 20% 0 0% 16.1 15.0
Newyorkbrad 370 0 0% 0 0% 328 89% 38 10% 4 1% 292 89% 36 11% 94 25% 6.7 1.0
Risker 370 34 9% 39 12% 261 88% 13 4% 23 8% 243 93% 18 7% 1 0% 7.1 3.0
Rlevse 370 157 42% 0 0% 154 72% 0 0% 59 28% 142 92% 12 8% 4 1% 5.4 3.0
Roger Davies 370 0 0% 26 7% 272 79% 4 1% 68 20% 220 81% 52 19% 97 26% 7.3 2.5
Shell Kinney 370 23 6% 0 0% 341 98% 5 1% 1 0% 304 89% 37 11% 42 11% 5.5 2.0
SirFozzie 370 0 0% 134 36% 207 88% 11 5% 18 8% 194 94% 13 6% 3 1% 2.1 1.0
Steve Smith 370 109 29% 173 66% 68 77% 5 6% 15 17% 65 96% 3 4% 2 1% 1.1 1.0
Vassyana 23 0 0% 0 0% 20 87% 3 13% 0 0% 17 85% 3 15% 0 0% 1.3 1.0
Wizardman 82 82 100% 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0%

Arb activity (departing 2009)

[edit]
Arb activity (departing 2009) — case proposals
Arb EP I % R % V % A % DNA % S % O % FS % ATV MTV
FloNight 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Stephen Bain 23 0 0% 0 0% 22 96% 1 4% 0 0% 22 100% 0 0% 21 91% 0.2 0.0